🌱 SEL Connection
Competencies: Social Awareness · Self-Awareness · Responsible Decision-MakingThis lesson addresses one of the most common and damaging misunderstandings in school life: when a student doesn't know what "good work" looks like, academic feedback feels like personal criticism. The teacher isn't attacking the student — the teacher is describing the gap between the work and the standard. This lesson helps students recognise that distinction, and gives them tools for understanding what is actually being asked of them.
📚 Cultural Connections (Teacher Only)
Many students — especially those from homes where school culture is unfamiliar — have never been explicitly taught how academic expectations work. They may not know that "your argument needs more evidence" is a technical instruction, not an insult. They may not know what a "good answer" looks like because nobody has ever shown them one. This lesson does not blame families. It acknowledges that academic literacy — knowing what teachers want and why — is a skill that must be taught, and that not all students arrive with equal access to it.Sensitive note: Some students may have experienced genuinely unfair or unkind treatment from teachers. The lesson is not designed to dismiss those experiences. The framing is: the first question to ask is always whether the feedback is about the work — and if it is, how to use it.
Central distinction: There are two very different things a teacher can mean when they give negative feedback: (1) your work does not meet the standard yet — a technical message about the work; (2) I don't like you / I'm against you — a personal message. Most of the time, teachers mean the first. Students who don't have academic literacy often hear the second. This lesson helps students learn to ask: "What exactly is the teacher asking me to change?"
Reading vs Listening — no repetition: The reading ("Oliver's Red Marks") follows Oliver, who sees red marks on his essay and concludes Mr. Webb is against him. Emma helps him read the comments carefully and realise they are all about specific things he can change — not about him as a person. The listening follows Kate, who thinks Ms. Hart picks on her in science. Tom helps her discover that she has been trying to do the right thing in the wrong way — she didn't know what the standard was.
Key question to put on the board: "Is the teacher talking about my work — or about me?" Return to this at the end.
H1 Task B: 1. confused 2. feedback 3. standard 4. specific 5. explain 6. goal 7. improve 8. expect 9. meant 10. clear
H2 Ex 1: 1. Modal (should) 2. Present Simple 3. Past Simple 4. Modal (can) 5. There was/were 6. Present Continuous 7. Future Simple 8. Past Continuous
H2 Ex 2: 1. should 2. can 3. might 4. must 5. can
H3 T/F: 1T 2F (he thought they meant Mr. Webb didn't like him) 3T 4F (Emma helped him read them as instructions, not insults) 5T
H3 Comprehension 1: He saw lots of red marks and thought Mr. Webb was being unfair or didn't like his work / him personally.
H3 Comprehension 2: Emma showed him that each comment described something specific he could change — "add more evidence," "explain this point."
H3 Comprehension 3: The comments didn't change — Oliver's understanding of them changed. He stopped reading them as personal attacks and started reading them as instructions.
H4 T/F: 1T 2F (Kate’s answers were correct but not sufficiently detailed) 3T 4T
H4 Gap Fill: 1. specific 2. standard 3. explain 4. feedback 5. goal
It's the Work, Not You
Vocabulary
VocabularyGrammar
GrammarFill in: should / shouldn't / might / can / must
Complete each sentence with your own idea.
Reading
ReadingOliver's essay came back covered in red marks. He counted them: fourteen. Fourteen things wrong. He put the essay in his bag without reading the comments. He was sure what they meant: Mr. Webb thought his work was terrible. Mr. Webb didn't like his ideas. Maybe Mr. Webb didn't like him.
He was still thinking about it when Emma sat down next to him at lunch.
"What happened?" she asked.
"History essay. Red marks everywhere. Mr. Webb is just looking for reasons to give me a bad mark."
Emma took the essay out of his bag. "Can I look?"
She read the comments slowly. "Oliver. These are not insults. Look at this one: 'Add a specific date here.' That's an instruction. And this one: 'Your argument needs one more piece of evidence.' That's also an instruction."
Oliver looked. She was right. Every red mark had a comment. Every comment described something specific he could change. Nothing said "this is bad." Nothing said "you are wrong." It all said: "Here is what is missing. Here is what to add."
"I was reading it like it was about me," he said.
"It's about the essay," Emma said. "There's a standard — what a good essay looks like. He's showing you the gap between your essay and that standard. That's all."
"So he's not against me?"
"He's describing the work. Not you."
Oliver took the essay home. He spent an hour working through every comment. He added the dates. He added the evidence. He rewrote the conclusion. When he handed the next essay in, he understood what Mr. Webb expected. His mark went up by twelve points.
Look at a piece of your own school work. Find one teacher comment on it. Is it about the work — or about you as a person? What exactly does it tell you to change?
Listening
ListeningFirst listen: What does Tom discover about Kate's answers? Second listen: Complete the tasks below.
Speaking
SpeakingSELNow that you finished the lesson: what are three signs that a comment is about the work — not about you as a person?
🌱 SEL Reflection
When Oliver saw fourteen red marks, he felt hurt. That feeling was real. But the marks were not about him — they were a map of what to fix.Academic feedback can feel personal. Sometimes it does feel personal — and that feeling is worth paying attention to. But the first question is always: what exactly is the teacher telling me to change?
If the answer is clear and specific, the comment is about the work. If you still don't know what to change after reading it — you need to ask.
Question to think about: Is there a piece of feedback you received and didn't act on — because you read it as criticism of you, not as an instruction for your work?
Writing
WritingSELWrite 80–100 words. Use at least four vocabulary words from Handout 1. Use at least one modal (should / can / must).

