אוסף אמין שנבנה מתוך ניסיון כיתתי עשיר על ידי שני מורים פעילים בהוראת אנגלית.

זה עובד. זה בדוק. פשוט, קל ובחינם.

Autonomy · Self-Determination · SEL
🧠Teacher’s Lesson Plan — A2–B1
Confidential 📄 Handouts →
Lesson Overview
Topic
The right and responsibility to think and decide for yourself. The difference between choosing to follow others and following others without thinking. What does it mean to own a decision? Why is it hard — and why does it matter?
Central question
“Think of a decision you made recently. Did you make it yourself — or did someone else make it for you without you noticing?”
Level
A2–B1
Duration
90 minutes
Grammar ★
by + V-ing — expressing how or by what means something comes about. “She found her path by asking herself what she really wanted.” / “By deciding for yourself, you take responsibility.” / “By not thinking, you let others decide.”
Key distinction
by asking (your own thinking) vs. by following (someone else’s thinking). The lesson’s core tension sits inside the star structure itself.
Characters
Zara (15) & Ben (14) (reading)  |  Tom (15) & Lily (14) (listening)
Hook
Write on the board: “Name a decision you made this week. How did you make it?” Collect. Categorise on board: A = decided myself / B = followed others / C = didn’t really think. Ask: which category appears most? Is C more common than people expect?
Vocabulary
decide · choice · opinion · influence · independent · consequence · responsibility · peer pressure · confident · path
Debate
H5: “Following the advice of people who know more than you is always the right decision.” Two teams. 3 min each + 2 min response. Use by + V-ing and vocabulary.
Writing
80–100 words · 3+ by + V-ing · 4+ vocab · Option C: letter to a younger person
Background for the Teacher
Choosing vs. not choosing

The key insight of this lesson is that not making a decision is itself a decision — by default, someone else or some habit makes it for you. Many students confuse following peer pressure with having no choice. The lesson aims to surface this: you always have a choice. The question is whether you make it consciously or not.

Autonomy is not contrarianism
Thinking for yourself does not mean always disagreeing with others. It means arriving at your position by your own thinking rather than by reflex, habit, or social pressure. You can think for yourself and reach the same conclusion as everyone around you — what matters is the process, not the destination. A student who follows advice after evaluating it is exercising autonomy. A student who follows it without thinking is not.
Grammar connection

The by + V-ing structure fits this theme perfectly: it captures the means by which autonomy works or fails. “By asking yourself” vs. “by asking others” vs. “by not asking at all” — the same grammatical slot holds the lesson’s key contrast.

📚  Further Resources for the Teacher

BookRobert Cialdini: Influence (1984) — Chapter on social proof. Why we look to others to decide what is correct. Very accessible teacher background.
BookSusan Cain: Quiet (2012) — Chapter on the extrovert ideal and the pressure to conform in group settings. Excellent for teacher background.
TED TalkDerek Sivers: “How to start a movement” (3:09) — A short, funny illustration of how following becomes a force of its own.
Key Grammar — by + V-ing

By + gerund expresses the means or method of achieving something. It answers the question “how?” — not what you do, but how you do it. In this lesson it naturally pairs with the theme of autonomous vs. dependent decision-making.

Positive — the means of good thinking
“By thinking for herself, she took responsibility for her future.”
“By asking himself what he really wanted, he found his answer.”
“She became more confident by making her own mistakes, not by avoiding them.”
Negative — the means of not thinking
“By not deciding, he let others decide for him.”
“By always following others, she lost her own direction.”
“You learn nothing by waiting for someone else to tell you what to want.”
Contrast pair
“She grew by facing the choice, not by avoiding it.”
“By deciding for himself, he changed — not by following the crowd.”
⚠  Critical errors:
× “She succeeded by to think” → ✓ by thinking
× “By she decided” → ✓ by deciding
× “He did it by not ask” → ✓ by not asking
Lesson Procedure
Time
Stage
Skill
Teacher does
Students do
0–8
Hook
Speaking
Board: “Name a decision you made this week. How?” Categorise: A=self / B=followed / C=didn’t think. Count. Discuss: is C more common than you expected?
Reflect. Share.
8–19
H1 Vocab
Vocab
10 words. Key: peer pressure vs. influence. consequence. path. Notice by+V-ing in each example.
Study. Match. Fill.
19–33
H2 Grammar
Grammar
by + V-ing. Means of action. Positive / negative / contrast. Exercises 1–3.
Study. Exercises.
33–52
H3 Reading
Reading
‘Your Call.’ Zara & Ben. T/F/NS. Questions. Grammar hunt.
Read. Tasks.
52–65
H4 Listening
Listening
Tom & Lily. Read TWICE. MCQ. Notes.
MCQ. Notes.
65–77
H5 Debate
Speaking
“Following advice from people who know more is always right.” 2 teams × 3 min + 2 min response. by+V-ing required.
Debate.
77–90
H6 Writing
Writing
80–100 words. 3+ by+V-ing + 4 vocab. Option C: letter to a younger person.
Write.
Listening Script — ‘But What Do YOU Think?’
Tom (15) and Lily (14). Tom is about to choose a path because his parents want it. No passive, no perfect, no conditionals type 1/2. by + V-ing throughout. Read TWICE.
Lily:
Tom, I heard you’re applying to the science programme. Is that what you want?
Tom:
My parents think it’s the right path. They know more than me about these things.
Lily:
That’s not what I asked. I asked what YOU want.
Tom:
I’m not sure. But by choosing what they suggest, I avoid making a mistake.
Lily:
Or you make a different mistake. By not deciding for yourself, you stop learning how to decide at all.
Tom:
But I might choose badly.
Lily:
You learn by choosing badly sometimes. That’s how you get better at it. By always following others, you never find out what you actually think.
Tom:
My parents just want the best for me.
Lily:
I know. And you can listen to them. But by listening and then deciding, you own the choice. By just following without thinking, someone else owns it.
Tom:
So what do I do?
Lily:
By asking yourself — honestly — what you want, you start. Not by asking me. Not by asking them. By sitting with it yourself first.
Tom:
And I might not know what I want yet.
Lily:
Then you find out by trying. By making small choices and paying attention to how they feel. That’s how you build a real opinion — by living it, not by hearing it from others.
by + V-ing (10+): “by choosing what they suggest” · “By not deciding for yourself” · “You learn by choosing badly” · “By always following others” · “By listening and then deciding” · “By just following without thinking” · “By asking yourself” · “Not by asking me” · “By sitting with it” · “by trying” · “By making small choices” · “by living it” · “not by hearing it from others”
Answer Key
H1 B: 1. influence  ·  2. peer pressure  ·  3. consequence  ·  4. independent
H1 C: 1. deciding  ·  2. choice  ·  3. responsibility  ·  4. confident  ·  5. opinion  ·  6. path
H2 Ex1: 1. by asking  ·  2. by not deciding  ·  3. by making  ·  4. by thinking  ·  5. by listening
H2 Ex2: 1. “by to think” → “by thinking”  ·  2. “by she decided” → “by deciding”  ·  3. “by not ask” → “by not asking”
H3 T/F/NS: 1. T  ·  2. F (Ben refuses to choose for her — he asks questions)  ·  3. T  ·  4. NS  ·  5. T
H4 MCQ: 1. b  ·  2. c  ·  3. b
H4 Notes: parents / mistake · deciding / choosing / better · listening / following · honestly / first / making / feel · living / hearing

🧠Think for Yourself

Autonomy & Personal Decision-Making — A2–B1 · 90 min
Name:  
Date:  
Class:  

Handout 1

Vocabulary

Vocabulary
Every day you make decisions. Some you make by thinking for yourself. Some you make by following others. Some you make by not thinking at all. Which type do you make most often?
Part A — Key Words

Study the key words. Notice how each example uses by + V-ing.

Word
Level
Definition
Example
decide
A2
To choose what to do after thinking about it.
"By deciding for herself, Zara took responsibility for her own future."
choice
A2
The act of choosing; what you choose between two or more options.
"By making a real choice, not just following others, you own the result."
opinion
A2
What you think or believe about something.
"She found her own opinion by thinking quietly, not by asking everyone around her."
influence
B1
The effect that a person or thing has on how someone thinks or acts.
"By noticing who influences your thinking, you can decide how much power to give them."
independent
B1
Not controlled by others; thinking or acting for yourself.
"By staying independent, she did not need others to tell her she was right."
consequence
B1
The result of a decision or action; what happens because of your choice.
"By thinking about consequences before deciding, she felt more confident in her choice."
responsibility
B1
The duty to deal with something; being answerable for your own choices.
"By deciding for yourself, you also take responsibility for what follows."
peer pressure
B1
The influence of people your own age to do what they do or want.
"By recognising peer pressure, you can ask: am I doing this by choice, or by habit?"
confident
B1
Sure of yourself; not needing others to confirm your decisions.
"She felt confident not by being certain, but by knowing the decision was truly hers."
path
B1
The direction you choose for your life; the course of action you take.
"By choosing your own path, you may walk it alone at first. But it is yours."
Part B — Match

Match each definition to the correct word.

1.The effect that a person or thing has on how someone thinks or acts → _______________
2.The pressure from people your own age to do what they do → _______________
3.The result of a decision or action → _______________
4.Not controlled by others; thinking or acting for yourself → _______________
Part C — Fill in

Fill in the correct word. Change the form if necessary.

decide  ·  choice  ·  responsibility  ·  confident  ·  opinion  ·  path
1.By _______________ for herself, Zara took control of her own future.
2.She felt it was a real _______________ because nobody made it for her.
3.By owning the decision, she also took _______________ for what followed.
4.She felt _______________ not by being certain, but by knowing the choice was truly hers.
5.By thinking quietly, she found her own _______________. She stopped asking what others thought.
6.By choosing her own _______________, she may walk it alone at first. But it is hers.

Handout 2

Grammar

Grammar
★  Star Structure — by + V-ing

By + gerund expresses the means or method of achieving something. It answers the question “how?” — not what you do, but how you do it.

Positive — the means of good thinking:
“By thinking for herself, she took responsibility for her future.”
“She found her answer by asking herself — not by asking others.”

Negative — the means of not thinking:
“By not deciding, he let others decide for him.”
“By always following others, she lost her own direction.”

Contrast pair:
“She grew by facing the choice, not by avoiding it.”
⚠  Critical errors:
× “She succeeded by to think” → ✓ by thinking
× “By she decided” → ✓ by deciding
× “He did it by not ask” → ✓ by not asking
Exercise 1 — Complete with by + V-ing

Complete each sentence using by + the gerund form of the verb in brackets.

1.  She found her own opinion _______________ herself what she really wanted. (ask)
→ _______________________________________________
2.  He gave up control of his future _______________ for himself. (not / decide)
→ _______________________________________________
3.  You learn about consequences _______________ your own mistakes. (make)
→ _______________________________________________
4.  She became independent _______________ carefully about each choice. (think)
→ _______________________________________________
5.  He changed _______________ to others first and then deciding. (listen)
→ _______________________________________________
Exercise 2 — Correct the error

Each sentence has one mistake. Find and correct it.

1.  “She succeeded by to think for herself.”
_______________________________________________
2.  “By she decided alone, she grew more confident.”
_______________________________________________
3.  “He lost his path by not ask the right questions.”
_______________________________________________
Exercise 3 — Write your own

Write three sentences about how people grow (or don’t grow) by their choices. Use by + V-ing in each.

1.  You grow _______________________________________________
2.  By always _______________ others, you _______________________________________________
3.  She changed _______________________________________________

Handout 3

Reading

Reading
Autonomy · Decision-Making · Identity

Your Call

Zara (15) sat at the kitchen table with two application forms in front of her. School A was five minutes away and all her friends went there. School B was forty minutes by bus and she knew nobody there — but it had the course she wanted. She called Ben (14).
Reading · A2–B1

“Which one should I choose?” she asked.

“I’m not going to tell you,” Ben said.

“Why not?”

“Because by telling you, I take the choice away from you. And then it isn’t your choice at all.”

Zara felt frustrated. She called three more friends. Two said School A. One said School B. She still felt stuck.

“You don’t find your answer by asking other people. You find it by listening to yourself.”

She called Ben again. “Everyone said different things. I still don’t know.”

“That’s because they answered their question, not yours,” Ben said. “By asking everyone else, you avoided the one question that matters: what do YOU want?”

Zara was quiet for a moment.

“The course,” she said. “I want the course.”

“Then you know,” Ben said. “By deciding that, you just chose School B. Not by anyone telling you. By yourself.”

Task 1 — True, False, or Not Stated?

Write T, F, or NS.

1.  Zara has two schools to choose between and she finds the decision difficult.[ T / F / NS ]
2.  Ben makes the decision for Zara by telling her which school is better.[ T / F / NS ]
3.  Asking her friends doesn’t help Zara find her answer because they answer their own question, not hers.[ T / F / NS ]
4.  Zara and Ben go to the same school.[ T / F / NS ]
5.  At the end, Zara finds her answer by herself — not because someone told her.[ T / F / NS ]
Task 2 — Answer the Questions

Answer in your own words. Write one or two sentences.

1.  Why does Ben refuse to tell Zara which school to choose?
_______________________________________________
2.  Why do her friends’ answers not help Zara?
_______________________________________________
3.  Find all by + V-ing structures in the text. Write them.
_______________________________________________

Handout 4

Listening

Listening
Tom (15) and Lily (14). Tom is about to choose a path because his parents want it. Your teacher will read TWICE.
Task 1 — Multiple Choice

Listen and choose the correct answer: A, B, or C.

1.  What is Tom’s plan for choosing the science programme?
A.  He decided by thinking carefully about what he wanted.
B.  He is choosing it because his parents think it is the right path.
C.  He researched all the options and selected the best one.
2.  What does Lily say about choosing badly?
A.  It is dangerous and you should avoid it by following expert advice.
B.  Making good decisions by practising is more important than avoiding all bad ones.
C.  You learn by choosing badly sometimes — that is how you improve at deciding.
3.  What is the difference between listening to parents and following them, according to Lily?
A.  Listening is polite; following is disrespectful.
B.  By listening and then deciding yourself, you own the choice; by just following, someone else owns it.
C.  Listening means you agree; following means you disagree.
Task 2 — Complete the Notes

Listen again and fill in the missing words.

But What Do YOU Think? — Key Points

Tom’s plan: applying to science programme. By choosing what his _______________ suggest, he avoids making a _______________.
Lily’s challenge: By not _______________ for yourself, you stop learning how to decide at all. You learn by _______________ badly. That’s how you get _______________.
Key distinction: By _______________ and then deciding = you OWN the choice. By _______________ without thinking = someone else owns it.
Lily’s advice: By asking yourself _______________, not by asking others. By sitting with it _______________. Then by _______________ small choices and paying attention to how they _______________.
How you build a real opinion: by _______________ it, not by _______________ it from others.
Task 3 — Grammar Hunt

Find eight by + V-ing structures in the conversation. Write each one.

1.  _______________________________________________
2.  _______________________________________________
3.  _______________________________________________
4.  _______________________________________________
5.  _______________________________________________
6.  _______________________________________________
7.  _______________________________________________
8.  _______________________________________________

Handout 5

Speaking

Speaking
Discussion

Discuss with a partner. Use vocabulary and grammar from the lesson.

1.Return to the hook. Look at the decisions on the board. Which of the category C decisions (not really thinking) would you change now? What could you do differently by thinking more carefully?
2.Lily says: “By always following others, you never find out what you actually think.” Do you agree? Can you think of a situation where this is wrong?
3.Ben says: “By telling you, I take the choice away from you.” Is this always true? When is it right to tell someone what to do?
🔥  Debate
🔥 “Following the advice of people who know more than you is always the right decision.”

Rules: Two teams. 3 minutes each to argue your position. 2 minutes to respond. Use at least two by + V-ing structures and two vocabulary words from Handout 1 per team.

🟢  FOR — Follow the experts By following people with experience, you avoid unnecessary mistakes. By listening to those who know more, you save time. By respecting their knowledge, you grow faster than by learning everything alone.
🔴  AGAINST — Think for yourself By always following others, you stop developing your own judgment. By making your own choices, even bad ones, you learn. Nobody else lives your life — by giving the decision to someone else, you give your path away too.

💡 Required: 2+ by + V-ing per team · 2 vocabulary words per team · respond directly to the other team’s argument


Handout 6

Writing

Writing
Writing Task

Choose one option. Write 80–100 words. Use at least three by + V-ing structures and four vocabulary words from Handout 1.

Option A — Personal: Describe a decision you made by thinking for yourself and a decision you made by following others. Which felt more like yours? What did you learn by each experience?

Option B — Opinion: “You can only grow by making your own mistakes, not by following other people’s advice.” Do you agree? Give reasons and examples.

Option C — Letter: Write a letter to someone younger than you. Explain why it matters to think for yourself — and how they can start doing it. Use by + V-ing to show them how.
Must include: THREE by + V-ing  ·  FOUR vocabulary words  ·  80–100 words
Self-check:  [ ] 3+ by+V-ing  [ ] 4+ vocab  [ ] 80–100 words  [ ] No “by to think” or “by she decided”