The key insight of this lesson is that not making a decision is itself a decision — by default, someone else or some habit makes it for you. Many students confuse following peer pressure with having no choice. The lesson aims to surface this: you always have a choice. The question is whether you make it consciously or not.
The by + V-ing structure fits this theme perfectly: it captures the means by which autonomy works or fails. “By asking yourself” vs. “by asking others” vs. “by not asking at all” — the same grammatical slot holds the lesson’s key contrast.
📚 Further Resources for the Teacher
By + gerund expresses the means or method of achieving something. It answers the question “how?” — not what you do, but how you do it. In this lesson it naturally pairs with the theme of autonomous vs. dependent decision-making.
“By asking himself what he really wanted, he found his answer.”
“She became more confident by making her own mistakes, not by avoiding them.”
“By always following others, she lost her own direction.”
“You learn nothing by waiting for someone else to tell you what to want.”
“By deciding for himself, he changed — not by following the crowd.”
× “She succeeded by to think” → ✓ by thinking
× “By she decided” → ✓ by deciding
× “He did it by not ask” → ✓ by not asking
Think for Yourself
Vocabulary
VocabularyStudy the key words. Notice how each example uses by + V-ing.
Match each definition to the correct word.
Fill in the correct word. Change the form if necessary.
Grammar
GrammarBy + gerund expresses the means or method of achieving something. It answers the question “how?” — not what you do, but how you do it.
“By thinking for herself, she took responsibility for her future.”
“She found her answer by asking herself — not by asking others.”
Negative — the means of not thinking:
“By not deciding, he let others decide for him.”
“By always following others, she lost her own direction.”
Contrast pair:
“She grew by facing the choice, not by avoiding it.”
× “She succeeded by to think” → ✓ by thinking
× “By she decided” → ✓ by deciding
× “He did it by not ask” → ✓ by not asking
Complete each sentence using by + the gerund form of the verb in brackets.
Each sentence has one mistake. Find and correct it.
Write three sentences about how people grow (or don’t grow) by their choices. Use by + V-ing in each.
Reading
ReadingYour Call
“Which one should I choose?” she asked.
“I’m not going to tell you,” Ben said.
“Why not?”
“Because by telling you, I take the choice away from you. And then it isn’t your choice at all.”
Zara felt frustrated. She called three more friends. Two said School A. One said School B. She still felt stuck.
She called Ben again. “Everyone said different things. I still don’t know.”
“That’s because they answered their question, not yours,” Ben said. “By asking everyone else, you avoided the one question that matters: what do YOU want?”
Zara was quiet for a moment.
“The course,” she said. “I want the course.”
“Then you know,” Ben said. “By deciding that, you just chose School B. Not by anyone telling you. By yourself.”
Write T, F, or NS.
Answer in your own words. Write one or two sentences.
Listening
ListeningListen and choose the correct answer: A, B, or C.
Listen again and fill in the missing words.
But What Do YOU Think? — Key Points
Find eight by + V-ing structures in the conversation. Write each one.
Speaking
SpeakingDiscuss with a partner. Use vocabulary and grammar from the lesson.
Rules: Two teams. 3 minutes each to argue your position. 2 minutes to respond. Use at least two by + V-ing structures and two vocabulary words from Handout 1 per team.
💡 Required: 2+ by + V-ing per team · 2 vocabulary words per team · respond directly to the other team’s argument
Writing
WritingChoose one option. Write 80–100 words. Use at least three by + V-ing structures and four vocabulary words from Handout 1.
Option B — Opinion: “You can only grow by making your own mistakes, not by following other people’s advice.” Do you agree? Give reasons and examples.
Option C — Letter: Write a letter to someone younger than you. Explain why it matters to think for yourself — and how they can start doing it. Use by + V-ing to show them how.

