אוסף אמין שנבנה מתוך ניסיון כיתתי עשיר על ידי שני מורים פעילים בהוראת אנגלית.

זה עובד. זה בדוק. פשוט, קל ובחינם.

SEL Series
Teacher’s Lesson Plan
Confidential 📄 Student Handouts →
Lesson Overview
Topic
Systems thinking vs. event-based thinking. The difference between memorising rules and understanding the system behind them — and why understanding systems lets you apply knowledge to problems you did not study before.
Central question
“Is it better to know rules — or to understand the system behind them?”
Level
A2–B1
Duration
90 minutes
Grammar ★
instead of + -ing
Used to contrast a less effective approach with a more effective one — the grammar of “do this, not that.” Perfect for contrasting event-based thinking with systems thinking throughout the lesson.
Characters
Maya (14, reading — learns Dell, gets Lenovo, Mr. Osei explains the system)  |  Ana & Ben (15, listening — Ana memorises grammar rules separately and gets confused; Ben explains the verb system)
Key ideas
Event-based thinking (fixing each problem in isolation) vs. systems thinking (understanding the structure that produces the problem) · Transfer of learning · Rules vs. principles · Dell/Lenovo: if you understand the system, any device works
Vocabulary
10 words (A2–B1): system · rule · pattern · cause · symptom · apply · logic · connect · figure out · step by step
Writing
80–100 words · Personal / Opinion / Creative
Background for the Teacher
The core distinction

Event-based thinking: each problem is a separate event. You fix it, move on. If the same problem returns, you fix it again. You never ask why it keeps happening. A student who memorises “he goes” as a fact, then “he is going” as another fact, is thinking in events — a list of disconnected items.

Systems thinking: a problem is a signal from a system. Fixing the symptom does not fix the system. A student who understands that all English verbs share the same structural pattern — base, -ing, past, past participle — has a mental model. When a new tense appears, it is not a new problem: it is a new part of an already-known structure.

The Dell / Lenovo insight

This is the lesson’s central analogy. A student who learned to use a Dell by memorising button positions learned Dell. When given a Lenovo, they are lost because the positions changed. A student who understood that every computer has an operating system, a file system, a user interface, and a network layer — understood computers. The Dell and Lenovo are different implementations of the same system. Understanding the system means being able to navigate any implementation.

The same is true for grammar, for maths, for physics, for cooking, for social situations. Rules are implementations. Systems are the structure underneath. Teaching the system is harder but far more transferable.

What this means for teaching
The lesson does not tell students to stop memorising. It shows them that memorising individual rules without understanding the system underneath is inefficient — because each new rule feels like a new problem, and the student never gets to the point of not needing to memorise.
Cause vs. symptom

Event thinking treats symptoms. A headache? Take medicine. But if the headache comes back every week, taking medicine again is treating the symptom — not sleeping enough, not drinking enough water, too much screen time. The system that produces the headache never changes, so the headache keeps returning. Systems thinking asks: what is the structure that keeps producing this result?

Key Grammar — instead of + -ing

After instead of, always use a verb with -ing. It contrasts what someone does with what they should do, or a less effective approach with a more effective one. It fits this lesson perfectly because the whole topic is about doing things differently.

instead of + -ing — at the start of a sentence
“Instead of memorising each step, try to understand how the system works.”
“Instead of fixing the same problem again, find out why it keeps happening.”
“Instead of learning rules for each new case, look for the pattern they all share.”
instead of + -ing — in the middle of a sentence
“She looked for the logic instead of trying to remember the old steps.”
“He asked why it happened instead of just fixing it again.”
“She understood the system instead of memorising every rule separately.”
⚠  Common error: × “Instead of to learn the rules”  →  ✓ “Instead of learning the rules”
After instead of, always use -ing. Never use to + infinitive.

Word order: Instead of + -ing can come first (comma after the clause) or second (no comma).
“Instead of fixing it again, she looked for the cause.”  =  “She looked for the cause instead of fixing it again.”
Lesson Procedure
Time
Stage
Skill
Teacher does
Students do
0–6
Lead-in
Speaking
Board: “You learn to use a Dell laptop. Then the school gives everyone a Lenovo. What happens?” Let students predict. Then ask: “Why does knowing Dell not help you with Lenovo — unless you understood something deeper?”
Discuss. Predict.
6–17
H1 Vocab
Vocab
10 words. Key: system (parts that work together with a purpose — not just “a method”). symptom (a sign of a deeper problem — not the problem itself). figure out (use your understanding to find the answer). Parts A, B, C.
Read. Match. Fill.
17–31
H2 Grammar
Grammar
instead of + -ing. Error: instead of to + inf. Word order. Use lesson examples throughout: “instead of memorising steps...” Exercises 1–4.
Study. Exercises 1–4.
31–48
H3 Reading
Reading
‘The New Computer.’ Maya’s Dell → Lenovo moment. Mr. Osei explains the system. T/F/NS. Comprehension. Grammar hunt.
Read. T/F/NS. Answer.
48–61
H4 Listening
Listening
Read ‘The Grammar System’ TWICE. Ana & Ben. MCQ. Notes. Grammar hunt.
MCQ. Notes. Grammar hunt.
61–74
H5 Speaking
Speaking
Task A: event or system? Rate examples. Task B: discussion — own experience of learning rules vs. understanding systems.
Discuss. Use instead of.
74–90
H6 Writing
Writing
80–100 words. Must use 3+ instead of + -ing + 4 vocab words.
Choose. Write. Self-check.
Listening Script — ‘The Grammar System’
Ana and Ben (both 15). Ana keeps memorising grammar rules separately and gets confused when new ones appear. Ben explains why. A2–B1 grammar only. Read TWICE. Students do NOT see this script.
Ana:
I give up. We learned Present Simple. Then Present Continuous. Now Present Perfect. Every time a new tense appears, I have to start again. It’s like learning a completely new language every few weeks.
Ben:
They’re not different languages. They’re all part of the same system.
Ana:
What do you mean? They look completely different.
Ben:
Only on the surface. Every English verb has the same forms — base, -ing, past, past participle. When you learn one verb completely, you learn the pattern for all of them. Present Simple uses the base. Present Continuous uses the -ing form. Every verb follows the same logic.
Ana:
But I study each tense separately. My notebook has a different section for each one.
Ben:
That’s the problem. Instead of learning each tense as a separate rule, try to understand the verb system. Then a new tense is not a new problem — it’s just another part of something you already understand.
Ana:
So instead of memorising “he goes, she goes” as a fact, I should ask why?
Ben:
Exactly. The answer is: in Present Simple, verbs in the third person singular get an “s.” That’s a rule of the system, not just a fact to memorise. Once you understand the rule of the system, it applies to every verb — go, run, eat, think. All of them.
Ana:
So instead of adding new sections to my notebook, I should build one big picture of how the whole verb system works?
Ben:
Yes. Instead of collecting more rules, understand the logic that connects them. Rules are just the surface. The system is underneath.
Ana:
That is actually… completely different from how I study.
Ben:
I know. But it works. Instead of starting from scratch every time, you build on what you already know.
instead of + -ing in the script:
“Instead of learning each tense as a separate rule” · “instead of memorising ‘he goes’ as a fact” · “Instead of adding new sections to my notebook” · “Instead of collecting more rules” · “Instead of starting from scratch every time”
Answer Key
Handout 1
Part B: 1. system  ·  2. pattern  ·  3. symptom  ·  4. figure out
Part C: 1. cause  ·  2. rule  ·  3. logic  ·  4. apply  ·  5. connect  ·  6. step by step
Handout 2
Ex 1: 1. learning  ·  2. memorising  ·  3. fixing  ·  4. adding  ·  5. starting  ·  6. copying
Ex 2 (errors): 1. “to memorise” → “memorising”  ·  2. “to fix” → “fixing”  ·  3. “to learn” → “learning”
Handout 3
T/F/NS: 1. T  ·  2. T  ·  3. F (Priya had a Mac, not a Lenovo)  ·  4. NS  ·  5. T
Comprehension: Q1: She understood computers (OS, file system, network, UI) — not just Dell. Q2: She looked for logic instead of remembering old steps. Q3: any three instead of + -ing from text.
Handout 4
MCQ: 1. c  ·  2. b  ·  3. b
Grammar hunt: Instead of learning each tense as a separate rule · instead of memorising as a fact · Instead of adding new sections · Instead of collecting more rules · Instead of starting from scratch

Why Understanding Systems Matters

Rules vs. Systems — SEL · Student Handouts · A2–B1 · 90 min
Name:  
Date:  
Class:  

Handout 1

Vocabulary

Vocabulary
Part A — Key Words
Word
Level
Meaning and example
system
B1
A group of parts that work together with a shared purpose. A computer is a system: it has an operating system, a file system, a screen, and a keyboard — all connected. “Instead of learning separate rules, try to understand the system behind them.”
rule
A2
An instruction that tells you what to do in a specific situation. Rules are the surface of a system — they describe what happens, but not always why. “She memorised the rule but did not understand the system that produced it.”
pattern
B1
Something that repeats in a regular, predictable way. When you see a pattern, you can predict what comes next. “Instead of memorising each case, he looked for the pattern that connected them all.”
cause
A2
The reason something happens. The cause is different from the symptom — the cause is deeper. “She fixed the symptom again instead of looking for the cause.”
symptom
B1
A sign that tells you something is wrong — but not the problem itself. A headache is a symptom; not sleeping enough is the cause. “Instead of treating the symptom, find the system that produces it.”
apply
B1
To use something in a new situation. If you understand a system, you can apply that understanding to many different cases. “She understood the computer system and could apply that knowledge to any device.”
logic
B1
The reason or principle behind something — the “why” that makes it make sense. “Instead of memorising the answer, she looked for the logic.”
connect
A2
To join or link things together. Understanding a system means seeing how all its parts connect. “He started to connect the rules instead of learning them as separate facts.”
figure out
B1
To use your understanding to find the answer. When you understand a system, you can figure out things nobody taught you directly. “Instead of asking someone, she figured it out from the system she already understood.”
step by step
A2
One thing at a time, in a fixed order. Following steps without understanding the system works — until something changes. “She followed the steps exactly, but step-by-step learning did not help her when the device changed.”
Part B — Match the Description
1.A group of connected parts that work together with a shared purpose → _______________
2.Something that repeats in a regular, predictable way → _______________
3.A sign that tells you something is wrong, but not the problem itself → _______________
4.To use your understanding to find an answer that nobody gave you → _______________
Part C — Fill in the Gaps

cause  ·  rule  ·  logic  ·  apply  ·  connect  ·  step by step

1.She fixed the symptom again instead of looking for the _______________ that produced it.
2.The _______________ says “add -s in the third person singular” — but understanding why makes it easier to remember.
3.Instead of memorising the answer, he looked for the _______________ behind it.
4.When you understand a system, you can _______________ that knowledge to many different situations.
5.She started to _______________ the rules instead of treating them as separate facts.
6.Following instructions _______________ works — but only if nothing changes.

Handout 2

Grammar

Grammar
★  Star Structure — instead of + -ing

After instead of, always use an -ing form. It contrasts one action with another — what someone does vs. what they should do, or a less effective approach vs. a more effective one. It is the grammar of “do this, not that.”

Structure: instead of + verb + -ing
Instead of + -ing can come first (comma after) or second (no comma).

“Instead of memorising the steps, she looked for the logic.” (first)
“She looked for the logic instead of memorising the steps.” (second)
instead of + -ing — contrasting approaches
“Instead of memorising each rule separately, look for the pattern they all share.”
“Instead of fixing the same problem again, find out why it keeps happening.”
“Instead of starting from scratch every time, build on what you already know.”
instead of + -ing — in everyday situations
“Instead of taking medicine for her headache, she drank more water and went to sleep earlier.”
“He asked why it broke instead of buying a new one.”
“Instead of memorising the bus times, she understood the timetable system.”
⚠  Common error:
× “Instead of to memorise the rules…”
✓ “Instead of memorising the rules…”

After instead of, always -ing. Never to + infinitive.
Exercise 1 — Complete with the correct -ing form

learn  ·  memorise  ·  fix  ·  add  ·  start  ·  copy

1.  Instead of _______________ each tense as a separate rule, try to understand the whole verb system.
→ _______________
2.  Instead of _______________ “he goes” as a fact, ask why it has an “s.”
→ _______________
3.  He asked why it broke instead of _______________ it again.
→ _______________
4.  Instead of _______________ a new section to her notebook every week, she built one map of the whole system.
→ _______________
5.  Instead of _______________ from scratch every time, build on what you already understand.
→ _______________
6.  She figured out the new device herself instead of _______________ the same steps from her old one.
→ _______________
Exercise 2 — Correct the error
1.  “Instead of to memorise rules, try to understand the system.”
Corrected: _______________________________________________
2.  “He asked why it broke instead of to fix it again.”
Corrected: _______________________________________________
3.  “She looked for the pattern instead of to learn each case separately.”
Corrected: _______________________________________________
Exercise 3 — Rewrite using instead of + -ing
1.  She memorised the Dell steps. She did not look for the logic.  →  Rewrite: She looked for the logic…
_______________________________________________
2.  He bought a new device. He did not try to figure out the old one.  →  Rewrite: He tried to figure out the old one…
_______________________________________________
3.  She took medicine for the headache. She did not sleep more.  →  Rewrite: She slept more…
_______________________________________________
Exercise 4 — Write your own sentences
1.  Write a sentence about learning using instead of + -ing.
→ _______________________________________________
2.  Write a sentence about solving a problem using instead of + -ing.
→ _______________________________________________
3.  Write a sentence about your own study habits using instead of + -ing.
→ _______________________________________________

Handout 3

Reading

Reading
Learning & Systems · Technology

The New Computer

Maya learned to use a Dell laptop. Then her school gave everyone a Lenovo. Maya thought she knew computers. She was wrong — or so she thought.
Reading · A2–B1

Maya was 14 years old. Her school gave every student a Dell laptop at the start of the year. Maya practised every day. She learned where to find her files, how to save her work, how to connect to Wi-Fi. By the end of the first month, she felt confident.

Then the school changed. The next year, every student got a Lenovo laptop. Maya sat at her new computer and felt lost. The icons looked different. The buttons were in different places. She did not know where to start.

Her classmate Priya sat next to her and logged in immediately. Maya asked: “Did you use a Lenovo before?” Priya said: “No. I had a Mac. But I understand how computers work, so I can figure out any of them.”

Maya asked Mr. Osei, their IT teacher, to explain. He asked: “When you learned to use your Dell, what did you actually learn? Did you learn Dell — or did you learn computers?” Maya did not know how to answer.

Mr. Osei continued: “A computer is a system. It has an operating system, a file system, a network connection, and a user interface. These parts work the same way on every computer. Dell puts them in one place. Lenovo puts them in another. But the system is the same. If you understand the system, you can find things on any computer. If you only learned Dell, you learned Dell — nothing more.”

“Rules tell you what to do. A system tells you why. When you understand the why, the what becomes easy to figure out.”

Maya looked at the Lenovo. Instead of trying to find the same button in the same place, she asked herself: where does the operating system usually put the file manager? She looked at the taskbar and found it. Instead of trying to remember Dell steps, she looked for the logic.

By the end of the lesson, Maya could navigate the Lenovo. Not because she memorised new steps — but because she stopped memorising and started understanding.

Task 1 — True (T), False (F), or Not Stated (NS)?
1.  Maya learned to use her Dell by practising every day for about a month.[ T / F / NS ]
2.  When Maya got a Lenovo, she felt confident immediately.[ T / F / NS ]
3.  Priya used a Lenovo at her previous school.[ T / F / NS ]
4.  Mr. Osei also teaches mathematics.[ T / F / NS ]
5.  By the end of the lesson, Maya could use the Lenovo because she understood the computer system, not because she memorised new steps.[ T / F / NS ]
Task 2 — Answer the Questions
1.  What did Priya understand that Maya did not? How does this explain the difference between them?
_______________________________________________
2.  What did Maya do differently at the end of the lesson? Find the sentence in the text that shows this.
_______________________________________________
3.  Find two examples of instead of + -ing in the reading text.
1. _______________  ·  2. _______________

Handout 4

Listening

Listening
Ana and Ben are both 15. Ana is frustrated because every new grammar topic feels like starting again. Ben explains why. Your teacher will read the conversation TWICE.
Task 1 — Choose the Correct Answer
1.  What is Ana’s problem with learning grammar?
A.  She does not like the English language.
B.  She does not have enough time to study.
C.  Every new tense feels like a completely new topic because she learns each one separately.
2.  What does Ben say about the different English tenses?
A.  They are all completely different and students need to learn them separately.
B.  They are all part of the same verb system, with the same underlying forms.
C.  Present Continuous is the most important tense to understand first.
3.  What does Ben suggest Ana should do?
A.  Stop using a notebook and just listen in class.
B.  Instead of learning each tense as a separate rule, understand the logic that connects them all.
C.  Focus only on Present Simple and ignore other tenses for now.
Task 2 — Complete the Notes

The Grammar System — Key Points

Ana’s problem: she learns each tense as a _______________ rule. When a new tense appears, she feels she has to start _______________.
Ben’s explanation: they are not different languages. They are all part of the same _______________.
Every English verb has the same _______________: base, -ing, past, past participle.
Present Simple uses the _______________ form. Present Continuous uses the _______________ form. Every verb follows the same _______________.
Ben’s advice: instead of collecting more _______________, understand the _______________ that connects them.
Key idea: Rules are just the _______________. The system is _______________.
Task 3 — Grammar Hunt

Listen again and write down all the examples of instead of + -ing that you hear.

1.  Instead of _______________ each tense as a separate rule…
2.  Instead of _______________ “he goes” as a fact…
3.  Instead of _______________ new sections to her notebook…
4.  Instead of _______________ more rules…
5.  Instead of _______________ from scratch every time…

Handout 5

Speaking

Speaking
Task A — Event or System?

Read each situation. Is the person using event-based thinking (E) or systems thinking (S)? Discuss with a partner. Give a reason. Use instead of + -ing in your explanation.

Situation — E (event) or S (system)?
Every week, Mia fixes the same broken door hinge. She never asks why it keeps breaking.[ E / S ]
Kai learned to use one phone app very well. When a new app appeared, he could figure it out in ten minutes.[ E / S ]
Tom takes a headache pill every day. He never changes his sleep or water habits.[ E / S ]
Sara learned one programming language well. When she needed a second one, she only needed a few weeks — not months.[ E / S ]
A city keeps adding more lanes to a congested road. Every year, the road gets more congested.[ E / S ]
Task B — Discussion
1.Think about how you learn English. Do you learn rules separately, or do you try to understand the system? Give an example using instead of + -ing.
2.Mr. Osei says: “If you understand the system, you can figure out any device.” Can you think of another area of life where this is true? (maths, cooking, sport, music…)
3.Is systems thinking always better than following rules step by step? Are there situations where step-by-step is the right choice?

Handout 6

Writing

Writing
Writing Task
Choose one:
Option A — Personal: Describe a time when you tried to learn something by memorising rules, and what happened when something changed. What would you do differently now?

Option B — Opinion: “It is better to understand one system well than to memorise many rules.” Do you agree? Give your opinion with reasons and examples.

Option C — Advice: Write a short message to a new student who is starting to learn English. Explain the difference between learning rules and understanding the system, and give advice.

Word count: 80–100 words
Must include: at least three examples of instead of + -ing  ·  at least four vocabulary words from Handout 1
Self-check:  [ ] 3+ instead of + -ing  [ ] 4+ vocabulary words  [ ] 80–100 words