אוסף אמין שנבנה מתוך ניסיון כיתתי עשיר על ידי שני מורים פעילים בהוראת אנגלית.

זה עובד. זה בדוק. פשוט, קל ובחינם.

Behavioural Economics · Cognitive Bias · B2–C1
💸 Teacher’s Lesson Plan — B2–C1
Confidential 📄 Handouts →
Lesson Overview
Topic
The psychology and economics of the sunk cost fallacy. Why people escalate commitment to failing courses of action. Kahneman and Tversky’s loss aversion research. The Concorde fallacy as the defining historical example. Opportunity cost as the rational alternative framework.
Central question
“Why do rational people persistently make decisions based on costs they can never recover?”
Level
B2–C1
Duration
90 minutes
Grammar ★
Passive reporting structures — “It has been shown that sunk costs distort decision-making.” / “It is widely argued that loss aversion is the root cause.” / “The fallacy has been described as one of the most costly cognitive biases.” — C1 academic impersonal passive with reporting verbs.
Characters
Reading: The Concorde Fallacy (analytical article)  |  Listening: Dr. Rachel Okafor (47) & Leo Hartmann (35)
Key concepts
sunk cost · cognitive bias · loss aversion · escalation of commitment · fallacy · prospective · retrospective · opportunity cost · irrational · commitment
Writing
250–300 words · 3+ passive reporting structures · 3 vocab terms
Background for the Teacher
Loss aversion — Kahneman & Tversky

Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky established, through their Prospect Theory (1979), that losses feel approximately twice as painful as equivalent gains feel positive. This asymmetry — loss aversion — is the psychological root of the sunk cost fallacy. When we contemplate abandoning a failing investment, we experience the sunk cost as a loss. Continuing generates the (false) hope that the loss might yet be redeemed. This is not irrational in an evolutionary sense: in environments of scarcity, abandoning an investment is genuinely costly. But it produces systematic errors in modern decision-making.

The Concorde fallacy

The UK–French Concorde programme began in 1962. By the late 1960s, it had become clear that the aircraft would never be commercially viable — the operating costs were prohibitive and the market was too small. Yet both governments continued funding for decades, spending what is estimated to have been over £1.3 billion in development costs (roughly £15 billion today). The phrase “the Concorde fallacy” is now used in behavioural economics to describe any situation in which prior investment drives continued commitment to a losing project.

Escalation of commitment

Related but distinct: as investment increases, people not only fail to exit — they often increase commitment. It has been argued that this occurs because: (1) abandonment represents a public admission of error; (2) continued investment maintains the possibility of vindication; (3) the cognitive dissonance of having made a bad decision is resolved by believing it will eventually pay off. It has been shown that this pattern appears in business, politics, and personal relationships at equal rates.

Opportunity cost — the rational alternative
The rational framework: every decision has an opportunity cost — the value of what you give up by continuing with option A instead of switching to option B. The sunk cost is irrelevant. The only question is whether the prospective benefits of continuing exceed the opportunity cost of not doing something else. It has been suggested that reframing decisions in terms of opportunity cost — rather than sunk cost — consistently produces better outcomes.

📚  Further Resources for the Teacher

BookDaniel Kahneman: Thinking, Fast and Slow (2011) — Chapters 26–32 cover loss aversion, prospect theory, and sunk cost in full. The foundational reference.
BookRichard Thaler & Cass Sunstein: Nudge (2008) — Applied behavioural economics. Shows institutional examples of the fallacy at scale.
BookBarry Staw: “Knee-Deep in the Big Muddy” (1976, Organizational Behavior and Human Performance) — The original escalation of commitment study. Highly readable for an academic paper.
TED TalkDaniel Kahneman: “The Riddle of Experience vs. Memory” (20 min) — Broader cognitive bias context. ted.com
VideoSprouts: “Sunk Cost Fallacy” (2:44) — Clear explainer, free on YouTube. Good hook. youtube.com/watch?v=vpnxd31y0Fo
Key Grammar — Passive Reporting Structures

Passive reporting structures allow the writer to report findings, arguments, and conclusions without specifying who made them. They are central to academic and analytical writing at C1. They signal that a claim is widely held, research-backed, or part of established discourse.

It + passive reporting verb + that-clause
“It has been shown that sunk costs distort decision-making.”
“It is widely argued that loss aversion is the psychological root.”
“It has been suggested that awareness of the bias does not protect against it.”
“It is generally accepted that past investment should not influence future decisions.”
Noun/pronoun + passive reporting verb + complement
“The fallacy has been described as one of the most pervasive cognitive biases.”
“Loss aversion has been identified as the primary driver.”
“The Concorde project is estimated to have cost over £1.3 billion.”
“Escalation of commitment has been observed at all levels of decision-making.”
Common reporting verbs in this structure
Present: is argued / is suggested / is believed / is estimated / is considered / is reported
Present Perfect: has been shown / has been found / has been described / has been identified / has been demonstrated
With adverb: is widely argued / is generally accepted / is commonly believed / has often been observed
Register note: These structures belong to formal written English — academic papers, analytical essays, reports. They are rare in casual spoken English. They signal objectivity and distance — the writer is reporting consensus rather than personal opinion.

Compare: “I think loss aversion causes the fallacy.” (personal) vs. “It has been argued that loss aversion is the root cause.” (academic, impersonal)
Lesson Procedure
Time
Stage
Skill
Teacher does
Students do
0–8
Hook
Speaking
Write “CONCORDE” on the board. “The UK and France kept spending billions even after it was clear Concorde would never make a profit. Why?” Collect ideas. Don’t reveal yet.
Speculate.
8–20
H1 Vocab
Vocab
10 terms. Key: prospective vs. retrospective. opportunity cost as the rational alternative. escalation of commitment.
Read. Match. Fill.
20–35
H2 Grammar
Grammar
Passive reporting structures. Two main patterns. Register note. Exercises 1–4.
Study. Exercises.
35–54
H3 Reading
Reading
‘The Concorde Fallacy.’ T/F/NG. Comprehension. Grammar hunt: passive reporting structures.
Read. Analyse.
54–68
H4 Listening
Listening
Dr. Okafor & Leo. Read TWICE. MCQ. Notes.
MCQ. Notes.
68–79
H5 Speaking
Speaking
Seminar: Is the fallacy always irrational? Can it ever be adaptive? Organisations vs. individuals.
Argue. Use grammar ★.
79–90
H6 Writing
Writing
250–300 words. 3+ passive reporting structures + 3 vocab.
Plan. Write.
Listening Script — ‘The Cost of Not Stopping’
Dr. Rachel Okafor (47) & Leo Hartmann (35). Passive reporting structures throughout. Read TWICE. Students do NOT see this script.
Leo:
Rachel, it has long been assumed that people are broadly rational decision-makers. The sunk cost fallacy seems to challenge that assumption directly. How significant is it?
Rachel:
It is considered one of the most pervasive and costly cognitive biases we have identified. It has been observed across cultures, income levels, educational backgrounds, and professional expertise. It has been found that even economists — people who teach that sunk costs are irrelevant — fall for it in their personal lives.
Leo:
What drives it psychologically?
Rachel:
It is widely argued that loss aversion is the primary mechanism. Kahneman and Tversky demonstrated that losses feel roughly twice as painful as equivalent gains feel positive. So when you contemplate abandoning a failing investment, the sunk cost is experienced as a loss — and the mind resists that. Continuing generates the hope, however irrational, that the loss might yet be redeemed.
Leo:
And the escalation of commitment — where people don’t just fail to exit but actually increase investment?
Rachel:
It has been suggested that this happens for several reasons simultaneously. First, abandonment represents a public admission of error — and that triggers shame. Second, continued investment maintains the possibility of vindication. Third, the cognitive dissonance of having made a bad decision is resolved by believing it will eventually pay off. It has been demonstrated that this pattern appears in business decisions, military campaigns, relationships, and political projects at comparable rates.
Leo:
Does awareness of the bias help?
Rachel:
It has been shown that awareness reduces the effect — but does not eliminate it. What is more effective is reframing the decision. Instead of asking “how much have I invested?”, it is recommended that people ask: “if I had no prior investment, would I choose this now?” This is sometimes called the “clean slate” test. It has also been found that framing the alternative in terms of opportunity cost — what you gain by stopping — is more effective than simply noting what you lose by continuing.
Leo:
Is the fallacy always irrational?
Rachel:
It has been argued, compellingly, that it is not always maladaptive. In environments where resources are scarce and commitments carry reputational weight, persistence signals reliability. The problem arises when the signal becomes detached from any realistic prospect of success. It is generally accepted that the fallacy is most costly precisely where the stakes are highest — major projects, long-term relationships, irreversible career choices — because those are the situations where the emotional investment is also highest.
Passive reporting structures in script: “it has long been assumed” · “It is considered” · “It has been observed” · “It has been found” · “It is widely argued” · “It has been suggested” · “It has been demonstrated” · “It has been shown” · “it is recommended” · “It has also been found” · “It has been argued” · “It is generally accepted”
Answer Key
H1 B: 1. sunk cost  ·  2. loss aversion  ·  3. opportunity cost  ·  4. prospective  ·  5. escalation of commitment
H1 C: 1. cognitive bias  ·  2. retrospective  ·  3. irrational  ·  4. fallacy  ·  5. commitment
H2 Ex 1: 1. It has been shown  ·  2. It is widely argued  ·  3. has been described  ·  4. It has been suggested  ·  5. It is estimated
H2 Ex 2: 1. “Researchers argued” → “It has been argued”  ·  2. add “It is” before “generally accepted”  ·  3. “People show” → “It has been shown”
H3 T/F/NG: 1. T  ·  2. T  ·  3. F (they continued funding for decades, not stopped in the 1970s)  ·  4. NG  ·  5. T
H4 MCQ: 1. b  ·  2. c  ·  3. b

💸 The Sunk Cost Fallacy

Loss Aversion · The Concorde Fallacy · Escalation of Commitment — B2–C1 · 90 min
Name:  
Date:  
Class:  

Handout 1

💸 Vocabulary

Vocabulary
Part A — Key Terms
Term
Level
Meaning and example
sunk cost
C1
An investment of time, money, or effort that has already been made and cannot be recovered. It has been argued that sunk costs should have zero weight in rational decision-making. “The £1.3 billion already spent on Concorde was a sunk cost — it could not be recovered regardless of what happened next.”
cognitive bias
C1
A systematic error in thinking that affects judgments and decisions. It has been found that cognitive biases operate even in people who are aware of them. The sunk cost fallacy is one of the most pervasive. “It is widely argued that cognitive biases evolved in environments very different from modern decision-making contexts.”
loss aversion
C1
The tendency for losses to feel more painful than equivalent gains feel positive. It has been shown that losses feel approximately twice as painful as equivalent gains. Loss aversion is the primary driver of the sunk cost fallacy. “It has been demonstrated that loss aversion affects decisions across all income and education levels.”
escalation of commitment
C1
The tendency to increase investment in a failing course of action precisely because of prior investment. It is considered more extreme than simply failing to exit. “It has been observed that escalation of commitment appears in failing business projects, political campaigns, and long-term relationships.”
fallacy
B2
A mistaken belief or a flawed argument that appears valid. The sunk cost fallacy is the error of treating past investment as relevant to future decisions. “It has been argued that the fallacy persists because it feels emotionally correct even when it is logically wrong.”
prospective
C1
Relating to the future; forward-looking. Rational decisions are prospective — they consider only future costs and benefits, not past investment. “It is generally accepted that only prospective analysis produces rational outcomes.”
retrospective
C1
Looking back at the past. Retrospective analysis drives the sunk cost fallacy: focusing on what you have already spent rather than what you will gain. “It is widely argued that retrospective thinking distorts prospective decision-making.”
opportunity cost
C1
The value of what you give up by choosing one option over another. The rational alternative to sunk cost thinking: what do you lose by not doing something else? “It has been suggested that framing decisions in terms of opportunity cost consistently produces better outcomes than sunk cost thinking.”
irrational
B2
Not based on clear thinking; influenced by emotion rather than logic. The sunk cost fallacy is considered irrational because it uses irrelevant information to make decisions. “It has been found that even highly educated people behave irrationally when sunk costs are large.”
commitment
B2
A strong decision to continue with something; dedication to a course of action. Commitment becomes problematic when it is driven by sunk costs rather than future value. “It is argued that commitment driven by sunk costs is a form of psychological entrapment.”
Part B — Match
1.An investment already made that cannot be recovered → _______________
2.The tendency for losses to feel more painful than equivalent gains → _______________
3.The value of what you give up by choosing one option over another → _______________
4.Forward-looking; relating to the future → _______________
5.The tendency to increase investment in a failing course of action → _______________
Part C — Fill in

cognitive bias  ·  retrospective  ·  irrational  ·  fallacy  ·  commitment

1.It has been argued that the sunk cost fallacy is a _______________ — a systematic error in decision-making.
2._______________ thinking focuses on what you have already spent rather than what you will gain.
3.It has been found that even expert decision-makers behave _______________ when sunk costs are large.
4.It has been argued that the sunk cost _______________ persists because it feels emotionally correct.
5.Escalation of _______________ occurs when people increase investment in a failing project rather than stopping.

Handout 2

💸 Grammar

Grammar
★  Star Structure — Passive Reporting Structures

Passive reporting structures allow you to present findings, arguments, and conclusions without saying who made them. They are central to C1 academic and analytical writing. They signal that a claim is widely held, research-backed, or established in the field.

Pattern 1: It + passive verb + that-clause
“It has been shown that sunk costs distort decision-making.”
“It is widely argued that loss aversion is the root cause.”

Pattern 2: Noun + passive verb + complement
“The fallacy has been described as one of the most pervasive cognitive biases.”
“The Concorde project is estimated to have cost over £1.3 billion.”
Present passive — current consensus
is argued / is suggested / is believed / is estimated / is considered / is reported
With adverb: is widely argued / is generally accepted / is commonly believed
Present perfect passive — established findings
has been shown / has been found / has been described / has been identified
has been demonstrated / has been observed / has been suggested
Register: These belong to formal written English — academic essays, analytical reports, presentations. They signal objectivity.

Compare: “I think loss aversion causes the fallacy.” (personal, informal)
“It has been argued that loss aversion is the root cause.” (academic, impersonal ✓)
Exercise 1 — Complete with the correct passive reporting structure
1.  _______________ (show) that sunk costs distort decision-making even in professional contexts.
→ _______________
2.  _______________ (widely / argue) that loss aversion, not irrationality, is the root cause of the fallacy.
→ _______________
3.  The sunk cost fallacy _______________ (describe) as one of the most costly biases in organisational decision-making.
→ _______________
4.  _______________ (suggest) that reframing the decision in terms of opportunity cost reduces the effect.
→ _______________
5.  The Concorde development programme _______________ (estimate) to have cost over £1.3 billion.
→ _______________
Exercise 2 — Rewrite in formal academic style using a passive reporting structure
1.  “Researchers have argued that the fallacy appears in all cultures.”
_______________________________________________
2.  “People generally accept that past investment should not affect future decisions.”
_______________________________________________
3.  “Studies show that awareness of the bias reduces but does not eliminate it.”
_______________________________________________
Exercise 3 — Identify the register difference

Each pair contains an informal and a formal version. Which is appropriate for academic writing? Why does the other feel wrong in that context?

1.  A: “Everyone knows that loss aversion is the main cause.”    B: “It is widely argued that loss aversion is the primary driver.”
Academic version: ___  ·  Why: ___
2.  A: “It has been shown that the fallacy is universal.”    B: “The fallacy is obviously universal.”
Academic version: ___  ·  Why: ___
Exercise 4 — Write your own
1.  Use It has been shown that... to make a claim about cognitive bias.
_______________________________________________
2.  Use It is widely argued that... to introduce a debatable claim about sunk costs.
_______________________________________________
3.  Use Noun + has been described as... to characterise the fallacy.
_______________________________________________

Handout 3

💸 Reading

Reading
Behavioural Economics · History · Cognitive Bias

The Concorde Fallacy

In the 1960s, the British and French governments began developing Concorde — a supersonic passenger aircraft. By the late 1960s, it was already clear that the project would never be commercially viable. They continued funding it for another thirty years.
Reading · B2–C1

The Concorde programme began in 1962. Within a decade, it had become apparent that the operating costs would be prohibitive: Concorde required four times more fuel per passenger than a conventional jet, and the sonic boom it produced restricted it to transatlantic routes. The commercial market for supersonic travel was, it was quickly established, vanishingly small.

And yet the governments continued. It is estimated that total development costs exceeded £1.3 billion — approximately £15 billion in today’s money. Concorde finally entered commercial service in 1976 and flew at a loss for the remainder of its operational life until retirement in 2003.

“We have already spent so much. We cannot stop now.” — the logic that drove Concorde, and that drives the fallacy in every context.

Why they kept going

It has been argued that three forces drove the escalation of commitment. First, the political cost of abandonment: stopping Concorde would have required a public admission that billions of taxpayer money had been wasted. Second, the reputational dimension: Concorde was a symbol of Anglo-French technological prestige. Third — and most significantly from a psychological standpoint — the sunk cost itself. It is widely believed that the more you have invested in something, the harder it becomes to accept that the investment was misguided.

Loss aversion as the mechanism

It has been shown, through the work of Kahneman and Tversky, that losses feel approximately twice as painful as equivalent gains feel positive. This asymmetry — loss aversion — means that abandoning a failing project feels like incurring a loss, while continuing generates the hope, however irrational, that the loss might yet be redeemed. The sunk cost fallacy is, in this reading, less a failure of logic than a consequence of emotional architecture.

The rational alternative

It is generally accepted among economists and decision scientists that the correct framework is prospective, not retrospective: what are the future costs and benefits of continuing, independent of what has already been spent? The past investment — the sunk cost — is, by definition, irrelevant. It has been suggested that the most effective corrective is the “clean slate” test: would you choose to start this project today, with full knowledge of its current state, if you had invested nothing previously? If the answer is no, the rational decision is to stop.

Task 1 — True (T), False (F), or Not Given (NG)?
1.  The Concorde programme was already known to be commercially unviable within a decade of starting.[ T / F / NG ]
2.  According to the article, loss aversion means losses feel approximately twice as painful as equivalent gains feel positive.[ T / F / NG ]
3.  Both governments stopped funding Concorde in the 1970s when it became clear it would never profit.[ T / F / NG ]
4.  The article states that Concorde was used by more than five airlines at its peak.[ T / F / NG ]
5.  The article argues that the rational framework for decisions is prospective, not retrospective.[ T / F / NG ]
Task 2 — Analysis
1.  The article gives three reasons why governments continued funding Concorde. Summarise each in one sentence.
1.___  ·  2.___  ·  3.___
2.  The article says the sunk cost fallacy is “less a failure of logic than a consequence of emotional architecture.” What does this mean?
_______________________________________________
3.  Find five passive reporting structures in the article (It has been / It is / noun + has been). Write each one.
1.___  ·  2.___  ·  3.___  ·  4.___  ·  5.___

Handout 4

💸 Listening

Listening
Dr. Rachel Okafor (47) and Leo Hartmann (35) discuss the psychology and decision science of the sunk cost fallacy. Your teacher will read TWICE.
Task 1 — Choose the Correct Answer
1.  How widespread is the sunk cost fallacy, according to Dr. Okafor?
A.  It mainly affects people with low financial literacy.
B.  It has been observed across all cultures, income levels, and educational backgrounds — including economists.
C.  It is mainly a problem in large organisations, not individuals.
2.  What drives the escalation of commitment, according to Dr. Okafor?
A.  Overconfidence in one’s own abilities.
B.  Simple greed and desire for profit.
C.  Shame at public admission of error, the possibility of vindication, and resolving cognitive dissonance by believing it will pay off.
3.  What does Dr. Okafor say about the “clean slate” test?
A.  It has been shown to completely eliminate the fallacy.
B.  It is effective because it reframes the decision: “would I choose this now with no prior investment?” — combined with framing the alternative as opportunity cost.
C.  It only works for financial decisions, not personal ones.
Task 2 — Complete the Notes

The Cost of Not Stopping — Key Points

Scale: it has been observed _______________, income levels, educational backgrounds. Even _______________ fall for it in personal life.
Loss aversion: losses feel _______________ as painful as equivalent gains. Abandoning = experiencing the sunk cost as a _______________. Continuing = hope the loss might be _______________.
Escalation of commitment — three reasons: (1) abandonment = public admission of _______________; (2) continued investment maintains possibility of _______________; (3) resolves cognitive _______________ by believing it will pay off.
Awareness: it has been shown that awareness _______________ the effect but does not _______________ it. Clean slate test: “If I had _______________, would I choose this now?”
Also effective: framing the alternative as _______________ cost — what you gain by _______________.
Is it always irrational? It has been argued: not always. In environments where resources are _______________ and commitments carry _______________ weight, persistence signals _______________.
Task 3 — Critical Evaluation
1.  Write five passive reporting structures from the podcast. Classify each as present or present perfect.
1.___ [___]  ·  2.___ [___]  ·  3.___ [___]  ·  4.___ [___]  ·  5.___ [___]
2.  Dr. Okafor says the fallacy may not always be maladaptive. What is her argument? Do you find it convincing?
_______________________________________________
3.  She says awareness of the bias “reduces but does not eliminate” the effect. Why might that be?
_______________________________________________

Handout 5

💸 Speaking

Speaking
Seminar

Use passive reporting structures in your contributions. Reference the reading and listening.

1.Is the fallacy always irrational? Dr. Okafor argued it may not always be maladaptive. It has been suggested that persistence signals reliability in certain contexts. Is there a version of “staying with it” that is genuinely rational?
2.Organisations vs. individuals: It has been observed that the fallacy appears in corporate, political, and personal decisions at comparable rates. Are there structural reasons why organisations might be more vulnerable?
3.The Concorde test: “Would you choose this now with no prior investment?” Apply this test to something in your own life. Is there anything you are continuing primarily because of sunk cost?
4.Loss aversion as architecture: The article says the fallacy is “less a failure of logic than a consequence of emotional architecture.” Does framing it as architecture rather than error change how you think about it — or what to do about it?

Handout 6

💸 Writing

Writing
Writing Task
Choose one (250–300 words):

Option A — Analytical: It has been argued that “the past is irrelevant to rational decision-making.” Evaluate this claim in light of the Concorde case and the psychological research discussed in this lesson.

Option B — Argumentative: “It is widely argued that awareness of cognitive biases is sufficient to overcome them.” Do you agree? Use evidence from the lesson to evaluate this claim.

Option C — Personal reflection: It has been suggested that the sunk cost fallacy affects personal decisions as much as institutional ones. Reflect on a decision — your own or one you have observed — in which sunk cost thinking played a role. What was the rational alternative?
Must include: at least three passive reporting structures  ·  at least three vocabulary terms from Handout 1  ·  reference to loss aversion, the Concorde case, or Kahneman
Self-check:  [ ] 3+ passive reporting structures  [ ] 3 vocab terms  [ ] Concorde/loss aversion/Kahneman  [ ] 250–300 words