🌱 SEL Connection — B2–C1
Competencies: Self-Awareness · Self-Management · Social Awareness · Responsible Decision-MakingAt B2–C1, the lesson examines the psychology. Tangney's research: guilt-prone people show higher empathy and are less likely to repeat harmful behaviour. Brown's shame resilience framework. The shame-aggression link: when shame becomes intolerable, it converts to anger directed outward. Indirect Speech is the grammar of this topic — reporting research, quoting inner voices, capturing what adults say to children.
📚 Research (Teacher Only)
June Tangney: Guilt-prone individuals show higher empathy, are more likely to take corrective action, and less likely to repeat harmful behaviour. Shame-prone individuals are more focused on self-protection than on repair.
Brené Brown: "The Gifts of Imperfection" — shame is the fear of disconnection. The antidote is "shame resilience": recognise it, move through it without internalising it, return to connection.
John Bradshaw: "Toxic shame" = when shame becomes a core part of identity. Associated with addiction, depression, self-destructive behaviour. Distinct from healthy guilt.
Indirect Speech as the perfect grammar for this topic: "She told him he was a bad person" (shame induction) vs "She told him what he had done was wrong" (guilt induction). Same grammar, opposite moral effect. The tense shift in Indirect Speech mirrors the lesson's core shift — from identity to behaviour.
The counter-intuitive point to land: Shame does NOT produce better behaviour. Shame-prone individuals are MORE likely to repeat harmful actions — not less. The research inverts the common assumption. Give students time to push back; the pushback is productive.
The shame-aggression link: When shame becomes intolerable, it converts to anger directed outward. This explains much defensive, aggressive behaviour after criticism. Students may recognise this in themselves — or in people they know.
H1 Task B: 1. guilt 2. shame 3. remorse 4. empathy 5. adaptive 6. withdrawal 7. aggression 8. self-worth 9. repair 10. toxic
H2 Ex 2: 1. said 2. told 3. said 4. told 5. told 6. said
H2 say/tell: say (no object) / tell (needs object: tell her, tell him, tell me)
H2 backshift: am → was · did → had done · can → could · is → was
H3 T/F: 1F (not deliberate at start) 2T 3T 4F (guilt response — called, apologized, friendship recovered) 5T
H3 IS analysis: "She told herself she was a bad person" — direct: "I am a bad person" (am → was); "She told her that what she had said was thoughtless" — direct: "What you said was thoughtless" (said → had said, tense shift because the act precedes the reporting)
H4 T/F: 1T 2F (guilt-prone show HIGHER empathy) 3T 4T
H4 Gap: 1. empathy 2. shame 3. withdrawal 4. adaptive 5. repair
Shame vs Guilt
Vocabulary
Vocabulary · B2–C1Grammar
Indirect Speech · Sequence of TensesRead "Two Memories" (Handout 3) and find:
a. Two examples of Indirect Speech reporting inner thoughts ("She told herself...")
→ _______________________________________________
b. One example of Indirect Speech with a backshifted tense — identify the tense shift
→ _______________________________________________
c. One example of say and one of tell — and note how they differ
→ _______________________________________________
Use Indirect Speech with tell to show the difference:
Reading
Reading · B2–C1How does this connect to the idea of adaptive vs maladaptive emotions — and to Tangney's research? Use Indirect Speech in your response: "Grace suggests that...", "The reading implies that..."
→ _______________________________________________
Listening
Listening · B2–C1First listen: Why is guilt more adaptive than shame — according to the research? Second listen: Complete the tasks below.
Use the word bank to complete the summary. Some sentences paraphrase the dialogue rather than quote it word for word.
Using Indirect Speech, report what Nora says in response. Then give your own view: can guilt replace shame as a moral corrective — without the damage?
Nora argued that _______________________________________________My view: _______________________________________________
Speaking
SpeakingSEL🌱 SEL Reflection — The Research
Tangney's finding: Guilt is adaptive — associated with empathy, repair, and lower repetition of harmful behaviour. Shame is maladaptive — associated with withdrawal, aggression, and higher repetition.Brown's framework: Shame is the fear of disconnection. The antidote is shame resilience: recognise it, move through it without internalising it, return to connection.
The shame-aggression link: When shame becomes intolerable, it converts to anger directed outward. What looks like aggression is often shame that has nowhere to go.
The practical conclusion: "What you did was wrong" (behaviour) is more effective than "you are wrong" (identity). The first can change. The second feels fixed — and so it never does.
Writing
WritingSELWrite 120–150 words. At least four vocabulary words, three Indirect Speech structures, formal register.

