In In a Different Voice (1982), Carol Gilligan argued that dominant moral theories (Kant, Rawls) are built on autonomy and universal rules, while a significant moral tradition — particularly associated with women but not exclusive to them — reasons from relationships and care. What the ethics of care recognises is that we are not isolated individuals who then choose to form relationships. We are relational beings first. What this means for responsibility is radical: we are responsible not because we agreed to be, but because we are already in relationship.
Levinas argued that ethics begins not with rules or principles but with the encounter with another person — what he called “the face of the Other.” What the face does is call me to respond, to be responsible, before I have made any choice. I do not choose to be responsible for the suffering face before me — the responsibility is already there in the encounter. What Levinas identifies as the foundation of all ethics is this pre-voluntary, pre-contractual obligation.
What makes the ethics of attachment philosophically interesting is its asymmetry. When you form a bond with a child, an animal, a friend in need — their vulnerability creates your obligation. You did not choose their vulnerability. But the bond you created makes you responsible for it anyway. What is irreplaceable is not created by contract but by care.
📚 Further Resources for the Teacher
A wh-cleft sentence uses a what-clause as subject, followed by is/was and the focus of the sentence. It emphasises the most important information and is a hallmark of analytical and philosophical writing at C1.
“What makes someone irreplaceable is the bond you formed, not their qualities in the abstract.”
“What Levinas argues is that responsibility precedes choice.”
“What the face of the Other demands is a response before any deliberation.”
“The bond you formed is what makes them irreplaceable.”
“Relational responsibility is what care ethics places at the centre of moral life.”
“What changes when you form a bond is your moral position towards the other.”
It-cleft: “It is the bond you formed that makes them irreplaceable.” (emphasises the bond)
Wh-cleft: “What makes them irreplaceable is the bond you formed.” (announces what the answer is, then delivers it)
Both are C1. Wh-cleft is more analytical; it-cleft is more emphatic.
Answer Key
We Are Responsible for Those We Care For
Vocabulary
Vocabularyrelational ethics · reciprocal · inherent · autonomy · attachment
Grammar
GrammarA wh-cleft sentence uses a what-clause as subject, followed by is/was, then delivers the focus. It announces that an answer is coming, then gives it. It is the grammar of analytical argument — especially useful when you want to foreground an idea before naming it.
“What the ethics of care recognises is that we are relational beings first.”
“What makes someone irreplaceable is the bond you formed, not their qualities in the abstract.”
“What Levinas argues is that responsibility precedes choice.”
“What changes when you form a bond is your moral position.”
“A response before deliberation is what the face of the Other demands.”
“Relational obligation is what care ethics places at the centre of moral life.”
It-cleft: “It is the bond you formed that makes them irreplaceable.” (emphatic, stresses the bond over other factors)
Rewrite using the reversed form: focus + is + what-clause.
Reading
ReadingThe Ethics of the Bond
What the philosopher Carol Gilligan identified in her foundational work is a mode of moral reasoning that had been systematically overlooked by mainstream ethics: reasoning from care and relationship, rather than from rules and rights. What makes this mode of reasoning philosophically significant is not that it is softer or more emotional, but that it starts from a different premise. Where rights-based ethics begins with autonomous individuals who then enter into agreements, care ethics begins with the observation that we are already in relationships — and that those relationships constitute our moral world before we have had a chance to choose anything.
Obligation without consent
What is philosophically provocative about the ethics of the bond is the claim that obligation can precede consent. You did not choose your child’s needs. You did not choose your friend’s vulnerability. You did not agree to be responsible for the animal that depends on you before the bond was formed. And yet what the bond creates is an obligation that feels, to anyone who has genuinely cared for another being, as real as any contractual duty — and considerably more urgent.
Levinas: the face of the Other
What Emmanuel Levinas placed at the centre of his ethics was the encounter with another vulnerable being — what he called the “face of the Other.” What the face does, for Levinas, is interrupt my self-sufficiency. It calls me to respond. What is radical about this claim is that the obligation is not a conclusion I reach after deliberation: it is something I discover myself to be already in the moment of genuine encounter. Responsibility, in Levinas’s account, precedes freedom. I do not first decide to be a moral agent and then become responsible. What I discover, in the encounter with the Other, is that I already am.
What this means for everyday relationships
What follows from this philosophical tradition is not a licence for unlimited obligation but a different starting point. What care ethics insists on is that the bonds we form — with partners, children, friends, animals, communities — are not peripheral to our moral lives. They are constitutive of them. What makes you who you are morally is not primarily the abstract principles you endorse. What it is, more fundamentally, is the particular relationships you sustain and the obligations you honour within them.
Listening
ListeningThe Obligation Before the Choice — Key Points
Speaking
SpeakingUse wh-cleft sentences in your contributions. Reference the reading and listening.
Writing
WritingOption A — Analytical: Evaluate the claim that “what makes you who you are morally is not the abstract principles you hold but the particular relationships you sustain.” Use concepts from this lesson: care ethics, Levinas, obligation, asymmetry.
Option B — Argumentative: “Responsibility without consent is not genuine responsibility — it is simply obligation imposed by circumstance.” Argue for or against this claim.
Option C — Personal reflection: Reflect on a relationship in your own life where responsibility emerged from the bond rather than from a conscious choice. What does care ethics say about that kind of obligation? Do you find the philosophical account convincing?

