(1) Self-undermining positivism: “Only verifiable propositions are meaningful” is itself not verifiable. Logical positivism is thought to have collapsed partly for this reason. (2) Tacit knowledge (Polanyi): Most expert performance is thought to rest on knowledge that cannot be articulated or proved — the master chess player, the experienced clinician, the skilled teacher. (3) Beauty: The experience of beauty is known to occur and to have real effects, even though beauty cannot be quantified. Reductionism is said to miss something real here. (4) Meaning: Human beings are known to need meaning. But meaning is not verifiable. It is inferred from experience, relationship, and a sense — not itself provable — that what one does connects to something larger.
X is thought to + inf: “Tacit knowledge is thought to underpin most expert performance.”
X is believed to + inf: “Beauty is believed to have effects that science cannot fully explain.”
X is known to + inf: “Intuition is known to play a role in scientific discovery.”
X is said to + inf: “Reductionism is said to miss something essential about the experience of beauty.”
X seems to + inf: “The claim seems to be self-undermining on closer examination.”
With have + past participle (perfect):
“Logical positivism is thought to have collapsed partly because its central claim was not itself verifiable.”
“Intuition is known to have guided many of the most important scientific discoveries.”
“Beauty is real” (direct assertion) vs “Beauty is believed to be real” (inference, attribution, epistemic humility)
⚠ Different verbs signal different sources:
“is thought to” — general view, inference
“is known to” — established, well-supported
“is said to” — reported, attributed to others
“is believed to” — widely held, conviction without proof
“seems to” — appearance, tentative inference
Not Everything Can Be Proved
Vocabulary
Vocabulary“What is essential is invisible to the eye.”
Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, The Little Prince (1943)Fill in the correct term. Each sentence uses Complex Subject.
Grammar
GrammarUse Complex Subject to report what people think, believe, or know about something — signalling that the knowledge comes through inference rather than direct observation.
X is thought to + inf: “Tacit knowledge IS THOUGHT TO underpin most expert performance.”
X is believed to + inf: “Beauty IS BELIEVED TO have effects that science cannot fully explain.”
X is known to + inf: “Intuition IS KNOWN TO play a role in scientific discovery.”
X is said to + inf: “Reductionism IS SAID TO miss something essential about the experience of beauty.”
X seems to + inf: “The claim SEEMS TO be self-undermining on closer examination.”
Perfect form — with have + past participle:
“Logical positivism IS THOUGHT TO HAVE collapsed because its central claim was not itself verifiable.”
“Intuition IS KNOWN TO HAVE guided many of the most important scientific discoveries.”
“is thought to” — general inference, tentative
“is known to” — established, well-supported
“is said to” — reported, attributed to others
“is believed to” — widely held, conviction
“seems to” — appearance, tentative
⚠ The structure itself enacts the lesson’s theme:
“Beauty is real” (direct assertion) vs “Beauty is believed to be real” (we know this through inference, not direct observation — which is honest)
⚠ Combine naturally with much as and in that:
“Meaning IS KNOWN TO matter for wellbeing, much as it resists measurement.”
“Tacit knowledge IS SIGNIFICANT in that it cannot be reduced to explicit rules.”
Rewrite using the Complex Subject form indicated. Use the correct epistemic verb.
Complete with a suitable Complex Subject structure.
Write four Complex Subject sentences about knowledge, proof, beauty, meaning, or intuition. Use a different epistemic verb each time.
“Tacit knowledge is thought to be irreducible to explicit rules, much as the expert may try to articulate what they know. The knowledge is said to reside in the doing, not the explaining.”
“Positivism is thought to be self-undermining in that its central claim fails its own test: the assertion that only verifiable statements are meaningful is itself not verifiable.”
Reading
ReadingNot Everything Can Be Proved
The self-undermining claim
The most common version of narrow empiricism holds that only what can be verified counts as genuine knowledge. This position is thought to be rigorous. But it is also known to be self-undermining: the claim that only verifiable propositions are meaningful is itself not verifiable. Logical positivism — the philosophical school most associated with this position — is thought to have collapsed partly for this reason. Much as the framework seems intellectually clean, it is said to have consumed itself. A theory of knowledge that excludes its own central claim does not survive close examination.
What we know without being able to say
The philosopher Michael Polanyi argued that we know more than we can tell. Tacit knowledge — the knowledge that underlies expert performance — is thought to be the most reliable knowledge in many domains, yet it resists explicit formulation. A skilled surgeon is known to recognise warning signs that they cannot fully articulate. A master musician is believed to hear structural relationships that they cannot describe in theoretical terms. Much as this knowledge cannot be proved in the ordinary sense, it is said to be the knowledge most worth having. The person who only trusts what can be articulated and verified is not thereby wiser. They are simply restricted to a narrower band of what can be known.
Beauty, meaning, and the limits of measurement
That a piece of music is beautiful is not verifiable in the ordinary scientific sense. But the experience of beauty is known to occur — and known to have effects on attention, wellbeing, and meaning that are real enough to study. Reductionism is said to miss something here: a complete description of the sound waves does not capture what the listener knows when they hear the music as beautiful. A similar case holds for meaning. Human beings are known to need a sense that their lives matter. This need is thought to be one of the most robust findings in psychological research. But meaning cannot be quantified or verified. It is inferred from experience. It is known through living, not through experiment. The claim that only provable things deserve belief risks closing off access to the forms of knowledge that matter most.
Listening
ListeningWhat We Know Without Proof — Listening Notes
Speaking
SpeakingRules: Two teams. 4 minutes each. 1+ Complex Subject + 1 much as + 1 vocabulary term.
Writing
WritingChoose one option. 250–300 words. 3+ Complex Subject structures + 3 vocab + 1 much as + 1 in that.
Option B — Argumentative: “A person who only accepts what can be proved is not more rational — they are simply blind to a large class of real knowledge.” (Dr. Osei) Argue for or against. Use at least three Complex Subject structures and in that to specify your most important claim.
Option C — Applied: Choose one form of non-provable knowledge: tacit knowledge, intuition, the experience of beauty, or the sense of meaning. Analyse what makes it a genuine form of knowledge, and what makes it different from mere feeling or opinion. Use Complex Subject throughout, and much as to acknowledge the limits.

