אוסף אמין שנבנה מתוך ניסיון כיתתי עשיר על ידי שני מורים פעילים בהוראת אנגלית.

זה עובד. זה בדוק. פשוט, קל ובחינם.

Knowledge · Proof · Intuition · Tacit Knowledge · Meaning · B2–C1
Teacher’s Lesson Plan — B2–C1
Confidential 📄 Handouts →
Lesson Overview
Topic
Four arguments against narrow empiricism: (1) The self-undermining claim — “only verifiable statements are meaningful” is itself not verifiable (logical positivism collapses). (2) Tacit knowledge (Polanyi) — most expert knowledge cannot be articulated, let alone proved. (3) Beauty as phenomenological knowledge — the experience is known even when it cannot be measured. (4) Meaning — perhaps the most important thing humans need, and not verifiable in any scientific sense.
Central question
“The claim that only provable things deserve belief is itself not provable. What does that tell us about the limits of proof as the test of what is real?”
Level
B2–C1
Duration
90 minutes
Grammar ★
Complex Subject (FULL FOCUS for this lesson) — X is thought to + inf · X is believed to + inf · X is known to + inf · X is said to + inf · X seems to + inf. “Beauty is believed to have effects that science cannot fully explain.” / “Intuition is known to play a role in scientific discovery.” / “Tacit knowledge is thought to underpin most expert performance.” The structure itself enacts the lesson’s theme: we know things indirectly, through inference, not only through direct observation. Perfect fit for the topic.
Grammar in texts
Complex Subject throughout (8+); much as (review); in that (review).
H2 review
much as + clause: write two sentences. in that + clause: write two sentences. These combine naturally with Complex Subject throughout the lesson.
Optional for teacher
📚  Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, The Little Prince: “What is essential is invisible to the eye.” Excellent opening quote.  |  Michael Polanyi, The Tacit Dimension (1966): “We know more than we can tell.”
Characters
Dr. Nadia Osei (45) & Dr. James Wren (47)
Key concepts
empiricism · verifiable · reductionism · quantify · scepticism · tacit knowledge · intuition · positivism · inference · phenomenological
Debate
H5: “A person who only accepts what can be proved is not more rational — they are simply blind to a large class of real knowledge.”
Writing
250–300 words · 3+ Complex Subject structures · 3 vocab · 1 much as · 1 in that
Background
Four arguments

(1) Self-undermining positivism: “Only verifiable propositions are meaningful” is itself not verifiable. Logical positivism is thought to have collapsed partly for this reason. (2) Tacit knowledge (Polanyi): Most expert performance is thought to rest on knowledge that cannot be articulated or proved — the master chess player, the experienced clinician, the skilled teacher. (3) Beauty: The experience of beauty is known to occur and to have real effects, even though beauty cannot be quantified. Reductionism is said to miss something real here. (4) Meaning: Human beings are known to need meaning. But meaning is not verifiable. It is inferred from experience, relationship, and a sense — not itself provable — that what one does connects to something larger.

Note on Complex Subject: in this lesson it is both the grammar star AND the structural enactment of the theme. When we say “beauty IS BELIEVED TO have effects that science cannot explain,” we are using a grammar structure that itself says: we know this indirectly, through inference, not direct observation. The form matches the content.
Key Grammar — Complex Subject (Full Focus)
Forms:
X is thought to + inf: “Tacit knowledge is thought to underpin most expert performance.”
X is believed to + inf: “Beauty is believed to have effects that science cannot fully explain.”
X is known to + inf: “Intuition is known to play a role in scientific discovery.”
X is said to + inf: “Reductionism is said to miss something essential about the experience of beauty.”
X seems to + inf: “The claim seems to be self-undermining on closer examination.”

With have + past participle (perfect):
“Logical positivism is thought to have collapsed partly because its central claim was not itself verifiable.”
“Intuition is known to have guided many of the most important scientific discoveries.”
⚠  The structure signals indirect knowledge — inference rather than direct observation:
“Beauty is real” (direct assertion) vs “Beauty is believed to be real” (inference, attribution, epistemic humility)

⚠  Different verbs signal different sources:
“is thought to” — general view, inference
“is known to” — established, well-supported
“is said to” — reported, attributed to others
“is believed to” — widely held, conviction without proof
“seems to” — appearance, tentative inference
Lesson Procedure
Time
Stage
Skill
Teacher does
Students do
0–8
Hook
Speaking
Optional: read aloud “What is essential is invisible to the eye.” (Saint-Exupéry) Then: “Can you think of three things that are known to be real but cannot be measured or proved?”
Think. Share.
8–20
H1 Vocab
Vocab
10 terms. All examples use Complex Subject. Key: empiricism, tacit knowledge, intuition, reductionism, verifiable.
Study. Match. Fill.
20–38
H2 Grammar
Grammar
Complex Subject — full focus. Five forms (thought to / believed to / known to / said to / seems to). Perfect form with have + pp. Different verbs = different epistemic force. Exercises 1–3. Review: much as (write 2). Review: in that (write 2).
Study. Exercises.
38–57
H3 Reading
Reading
‘Not Everything Can Be Proved.’ T/F/NG + 4 analytical questions.
Read. Tasks.
57–70
H4 Listening
Listening
Dr. Osei & Dr. Wren. Read TWICE. MCQ + Notes + Task 3.
MCQ. Notes.
70–80
H5 Debate
Speaking
“A person who only accepts what can be proved is not more rational — they are simply blind to a large class of real knowledge.” Complex Subject required.
Debate.
80–90
H6 Writing
Writing
250–300 words. 3+ Complex Subject + 3 vocab + 1 much as + 1 in that.
Plan. Write.
Listening Script — ‘What We Know Without Proof’
Dr. Nadia Osei (45) & Dr. James Wren (47). Complex Subject (8+). much as (3+). in that (3+). Read TWICE.
James:
Nadia, the position I want to examine is one we encounter regularly in educated adults: the claim that only what can be verified counts as genuine knowledge. It is a position that appears rigorous but turns out to be self-undermining in a specific way. The claim that only verifiable propositions are meaningful is itself not verifiable. Logical positivism is thought to have collapsed partly for this reason. Much as the framework feels intellectually honest, it is said to have consumed itself.
Nadia:
And there is a broader problem. Knowledge is believed to take forms that resist empirical verification entirely. Tacit knowledge — what Michael Polanyi described as knowing more than we can tell — is known to underpin most expert performance. A skilled surgeon, a master musician, an experienced teacher: each is thought to act on knowledge that cannot be fully articulated, let alone measured. Much as this knowledge resists explicit formulation, it is said to be the most reliable knowledge of all in its domain. The person who only trusts what can be proved is not thereby more rational. They are simply blind to a large class of real knowledge.
James:
The case of beauty is perhaps the clearest illustration. That a piece of music is beautiful is not verifiable in the ordinary sense. But it is believed to be known with certainty by anyone who has experienced it. The phenomenological reality — the experience itself — is known to occur. Much as science can describe the acoustic properties of the music, the description is not thought to be the same thing as, or adequate to, the experience. Reductionism is said to miss something here. The experience of beauty is known to have effects on wellbeing, attention, and meaning that are real enough to study — even if the beauty itself cannot be quantified.
Nadia:
The most interesting case is meaning. Human beings are known to need a sense that their lives matter. This is thought to be one of the most robust findings in psychological research. But meaning cannot be verified in the way a physical constant can. It is inferred from experience, from relationship, from the sense — itself not provable — that what one does connects to something beyond the immediate moment. Much as this is not the kind of knowledge that science produces, it is known to be the kind that makes life livable. The person who closes themselves off from everything that cannot be proved risks losing access to the forms of knowledge that matter most.
James:
The question of intuition deserves separate attention. Scientific discovery is known to depend on intuition as well as method. Many major breakthroughs are said to have begun with a sense that something was true before the proof existed — and the subsequent work confirmed, extended, or corrected what the intuition suggested. Much as this is not a licence for uncritical feeling, it does mean that the narrow empiricist position — that only verifiable claims deserve credence — is thought to be inconsistent with the actual practice of science. Science itself uses forms of knowledge that exceed what can be immediately proved.
Complex Subject (8+): “is thought to be one we encounter regularly” · “is thought to have collapsed” · “is said to have consumed itself” · “Knowledge is believed to take forms” · “each is thought to act on knowledge” · “is said to be the most reliable” · “is believed to be known with certainty” · “is known to occur” · “description is not thought to be” · “Reductionism is said to miss” · “Human beings are known to need” · “is thought to be one of the most robust” · “Scientific discovery is known to depend” · “Many major breakthroughs are said to have begun” · “is thought to be inconsistent”
Answer Key
H1 B: 1.empiricism 2.verifiable 3.reductionism 4.quantify 5.scepticism
H1 C: 1.tacit knowledge 2.intuition 3.positivism 4.inference 5.phenomenological
H3 T/F/NG: 1.T 2.T 3.F(article says beauty is known to have real effects on wellbeing) 4.NG 5.T
H4 MCQ:
H4 Listening Notes: 1. verifiable 2. collapsed 3. more 4. expert 5. occur 6. attention 7. matter 8. verified 9. intuition 10. sense
1.b 2.c 3.b

Not Everything Can Be Proved

Knowledge, Intuition, and What Lies Beyond Proof — B2–C1 · 90 min
Name:  
Date:  
Class:  

Handout 1

Vocabulary

Vocabulary

“What is essential is invisible to the eye.”

Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, The Little Prince (1943)
Every example uses the grammar star: Complex Subject — X is thought to / believed to / known to / said to / seems to + infinitive. The structure itself says: we know this through inference, not direct observation.
Term
Level
Definition
Example
empiricism
C1
The theory that knowledge comes primarily from sensory experience and verifiable evidence; here: as a powerful but incomplete approach to what can be known.
"Empiricism is thought to be the foundation of modern science. But it is also known to have limits: much as it excels at describing how the world works, it is not designed to address whether a life is meaningful."
verifiable
C1
Able to be confirmed or checked as true through observation or evidence; here: why restricting belief to what is verifiable leaves out much of what matters.
"The claim that love is real is not verifiable in the way that a chemical reaction is. But it is believed to be known by everyone who has experienced it — through a kind of evidence that proof was not designed to handle."
reductionism
C1
The approach of explaining complex phenomena by reducing them to simpler components; here: what happens when you try to measure everything that matters.
"Beauty is thought to involve neurological responses. But reductionism is said to miss something: the fact that a piece of music is beautiful is not fully explained by a description of the sound waves."
quantify
C1
To express or measure the quantity of something; here: what some forms of knowledge resist entirely.
"Trust is known to affect health outcomes. But the degree to which it matters cannot be quantified without losing what makes it meaningful. Not everything that counts can be counted."
scepticism
C1
A questioning attitude toward claims that lack strong evidence; here: healthy scepticism versus the kind that closes itself off from all non-verifiable experience.
"Healthy scepticism is thought to be essential to honest inquiry. But excessive scepticism — the refusal to accept any knowledge that cannot be proved — is said to be its own form of closed-mindedness."
tacit knowledge
C1
Knowledge that is difficult to articulate or transfer through writing; knowing more than you can tell (Polanyi); here: what expert intuition actually consists of.
"A master chess player is thought to see the right move before calculating why. This tacit knowledge — real enough to win championships — is believed to be irreducible to explicit rules."
intuition
C1
The ability to understand something without conscious reasoning; here: as a form of knowledge that is real but not directly provable.
"Scientific discovery is known to depend on intuition as well as method. Many major breakthroughs are said to have begun with a feeling that something was true before the proof existed."
positivism
C1
The philosophical position that meaningful knowledge is limited to what can be empirically verified; here: as a useful but self-limiting framework.
"Logical positivism is thought to have been influential in the early twentieth century — and is believed to have collapsed partly because its own central claim (that only verifiable statements are meaningful) is itself not verifiable."
inference
C1
A conclusion reached on the basis of evidence and reasoning; here: how we legitimately know things we cannot directly observe.
"We do not observe other people’s minds directly. Their inner lives are known only through inference — which is thought to be a perfectly valid form of knowledge, much as it cannot be proved in the way a physical fact can."
phenomenological
C1
Relating to direct conscious experience as a subject of study; here: the validity of subjective experience as a genuine form of knowledge.
"The phenomenological claim is simple: the experience of beauty, love, or meaning is real in that it genuinely occurs, regardless of whether it is verifiable. What is experienced is known, even when it cannot be measured."
Part B — Match
1.The theory that knowledge comes from sensory experience and evidence; here: as powerful but incomplete → _______________
2.Able to be confirmed or checked through observation; here: why restricting belief to what meets this standard leaves out much of what matters → _______________
3.The approach of explaining complex things by reducing them to simpler components; here: what misses something about the experience of beauty → _______________
4.To express or measure the quantity of something; here: what meaning and beauty resist → _______________
5.A questioning attitude toward claims without strong evidence; here: the difference between useful scepticism and the kind that closes itself off → _______________
Part C — Fill in

Fill in the correct term. Each sentence uses Complex Subject.

tacit knowledge  ·  intuition  ·  positivism  ·  inference  ·  phenomenological
1._______________ is thought to underpin most expert performance — the knowledge a skilled surgeon or experienced teacher acts on, which cannot be fully articulated or measured.
2.Scientific discovery is known to depend on _______________: the sense that something is true before the proof exists. Many breakthroughs are said to have begun this way.
3.Logical _______________ is thought to have collapsed partly because its own central claim — that only verifiable statements are meaningful — is itself not verifiable.
4.We do not observe other minds directly. Their inner lives are known only through _______________: a conclusion reached from evidence, not direct observation — and believed to be perfectly valid knowledge.
5.The _______________ claim is simple: what is experienced is known, even when it cannot be measured. The experience of beauty or meaning is thought to be real in that it genuinely occurs.

Handout 2

Grammar

Grammar
★  Star Structure — Complex Subject

Use Complex Subject to report what people think, believe, or know about something — signalling that the knowledge comes through inference rather than direct observation.

Five key forms:
X is thought to + inf: “Tacit knowledge IS THOUGHT TO underpin most expert performance.”
X is believed to + inf: “Beauty IS BELIEVED TO have effects that science cannot fully explain.”
X is known to + inf: “Intuition IS KNOWN TO play a role in scientific discovery.”
X is said to + inf: “Reductionism IS SAID TO miss something essential about the experience of beauty.”
X seems to + inf: “The claim SEEMS TO be self-undermining on closer examination.”

Perfect form — with have + past participle:
“Logical positivism IS THOUGHT TO HAVE collapsed because its central claim was not itself verifiable.”
“Intuition IS KNOWN TO HAVE guided many of the most important scientific discoveries.”
⚠  Different verbs signal different epistemic force:
“is thought to” — general inference, tentative
“is known to” — established, well-supported
“is said to” — reported, attributed to others
“is believed to” — widely held, conviction
“seems to” — appearance, tentative

⚠  The structure itself enacts the lesson’s theme:
“Beauty is real” (direct assertion) vs “Beauty is believed to be real” (we know this through inference, not direct observation — which is honest)

⚠  Combine naturally with much as and in that:
“Meaning IS KNOWN TO matter for wellbeing, much as it resists measurement.”
“Tacit knowledge IS SIGNIFICANT in that it cannot be reduced to explicit rules.”
Exercise 1 — Transform

Rewrite using the Complex Subject form indicated. Use the correct epistemic verb.

1.  “People think that beauty has real effects on wellbeing.” (is believed to)
→ _______________________________________________
2.  “Research shows that human beings need meaning to function well.” (is known to)
→ _______________________________________________
3.  “It is reported that intuition guided many major scientific discoveries.” (is said to have)
→ _______________________________________________
4.  “The position appears to be self-contradictory.” (seems to)
→ _______________________________________________
Exercise 2 — Complete

Complete with a suitable Complex Subject structure.

1.  Expert performance _______________________________________________ on knowledge that cannot be articulated. (is thought to / rest)
2.  Logical positivism _______________________________________________ because its central claim was not verifiable. (is thought to have / collapse)
3.  The experience of beauty _______________________________________________ even when it cannot be measured. (is known to / occur)
4.  The narrow empiricist position _______________________________________________ with the actual practice of science. (is thought to be / inconsistent)
Exercise 3 — Write your own

Write four Complex Subject sentences about knowledge, proof, beauty, meaning, or intuition. Use a different epistemic verb each time.

1. (is thought to):  _______________________________________________
2. (is known to):  _______________________________________________
3. (is said to have):  _______________________________________________
4. (seems to):  _______________________________________________
▶  Review — much as + clause
“Beauty is believed to have effects on wellbeing that science cannot fully explain — much as science can describe the acoustic properties of music, the description is not thought to be the same as the experience.”
“Tacit knowledge is thought to be irreducible to explicit rules, much as the expert may try to articulate what they know. The knowledge is said to reside in the doing, not the explaining.”
R1.  Write two much as sentences about knowledge, proof, or what science can and cannot explain.
_______________________________________________
R2.  Complete: “Meaning is known to matter for wellbeing, much as _______________________________________________”
_______________________________________________
▶  Review — in that + clause
“The phenomenological claim is significant in that it establishes experience as a form of knowledge that is valid independently of verifiability — the experience is known to occur, whether or not science can describe it.”
“Positivism is thought to be self-undermining in that its central claim fails its own test: the assertion that only verifiable statements are meaningful is itself not verifiable.”
R3.  Write two in that sentences about the limits of proof or the validity of non-provable knowledge.
_______________________________________________
R4.  Complete: “The narrow empiricist position is thought to be problematic in that _______________________________________________”
_______________________________________________

Handout 3

Reading

Reading
Knowledge · Proof · Beauty · Meaning · Tacit Knowledge

Not Everything Can Be Proved

Reading · B2–C1

The self-undermining claim

The most common version of narrow empiricism holds that only what can be verified counts as genuine knowledge. This position is thought to be rigorous. But it is also known to be self-undermining: the claim that only verifiable propositions are meaningful is itself not verifiable. Logical positivism — the philosophical school most associated with this position — is thought to have collapsed partly for this reason. Much as the framework seems intellectually clean, it is said to have consumed itself. A theory of knowledge that excludes its own central claim does not survive close examination.

“A person who only accepts what can be proved is not more rational — they are simply blind to a large class of real knowledge.”

What we know without being able to say

The philosopher Michael Polanyi argued that we know more than we can tell. Tacit knowledge — the knowledge that underlies expert performance — is thought to be the most reliable knowledge in many domains, yet it resists explicit formulation. A skilled surgeon is known to recognise warning signs that they cannot fully articulate. A master musician is believed to hear structural relationships that they cannot describe in theoretical terms. Much as this knowledge cannot be proved in the ordinary sense, it is said to be the knowledge most worth having. The person who only trusts what can be articulated and verified is not thereby wiser. They are simply restricted to a narrower band of what can be known.

Beauty, meaning, and the limits of measurement

That a piece of music is beautiful is not verifiable in the ordinary scientific sense. But the experience of beauty is known to occur — and known to have effects on attention, wellbeing, and meaning that are real enough to study. Reductionism is said to miss something here: a complete description of the sound waves does not capture what the listener knows when they hear the music as beautiful. A similar case holds for meaning. Human beings are known to need a sense that their lives matter. This need is thought to be one of the most robust findings in psychological research. But meaning cannot be quantified or verified. It is inferred from experience. It is known through living, not through experiment. The claim that only provable things deserve belief risks closing off access to the forms of knowledge that matter most.

Task 1 — True, False, or Not Given?
1.  The article states that logical positivism is thought to have collapsed partly because its central claim was not itself verifiable.[ T / F / NG ]
2.  The article argues that tacit knowledge is thought to be the most reliable knowledge in many domains, even though it resists explicit formulation.[ T / F / NG ]
3.  The article claims that beauty is not known to have any real effects on wellbeing.[ T / F / NG ]
4.  The article mentions a specific scientific study on the effects of beauty on the brain.[ T / F / NG ]
5.  The article concludes that the claim that only provable things deserve belief risks closing off access to the forms of knowledge that matter most.[ T / F / NG ]
Task 2 — Analysis
1.  The article says logical positivism is thought to have consumed itself. What does this mean? Use in that and a Complex Subject structure.
_______________________________________________
2.  The article says tacit knowledge is thought to be the most reliable knowledge in many domains. What is tacit knowledge? Why is it reliable even though it cannot be articulated? Use Complex Subject.
_______________________________________________
3.  The article says reductionism is said to miss something about the experience of beauty. What does it miss? Use in that.
_______________________________________________
4.  The article says meaning is “known through living, not through experiment.” What does this mean? Can you give an example from your own life of knowledge that is known through living? Use Complex Subject.
_______________________________________________

Handout 4

Listening

Listening
Dr. Nadia Osei (45) and Dr. James Wren (47). Your teacher reads TWICE.
Task 1 — Multiple Choice
1.  What does Dr. Wren say about logical positivism?
A.  Logical positivism is thought to be the most rigorous approach to knowledge, in that it is known to have produced the most reliable results in science.
B.  The position that only verifiable things count as knowledge is thought to be self-undermining: the central claim is itself not verifiable. Logical positivism is thought to have collapsed partly for this reason. Much as the framework seems intellectually honest, it is said to have consumed itself. A theory of knowledge that excludes its own central claim does not survive close examination.
C.  Logical positivism is said to be the most influential philosophical position of the twentieth century, in that it is known to have shaped all subsequent thinking about knowledge.
2.  What does Dr. Osei say about tacit knowledge?
A.  Tacit knowledge is believed to be less reliable than explicit knowledge, in that it cannot be verified or transmitted to others.
B.  Tacit knowledge is thought to be important but secondary, in that it seems to complement explicit knowledge rather than replace it.
C.  Tacit knowledge is thought to underpin most expert performance — the knowledge a skilled surgeon or master musician acts on, which cannot be fully articulated. Much as this knowledge resists explicit formulation, it is said to be the most reliable knowledge of all in its domain. The person who only trusts what can be proved is not more rational — they are simply blind to a large class of real knowledge.
3.  What does Dr. Wren say about intuition in science?
A.  Intuition is thought to be unreliable in science in that it is known to have led many scientists to incorrect conclusions that required correction by experiment.
B.  Scientific discovery is known to depend on intuition as well as method. Many breakthroughs are said to have begun with a sense that something was true before the proof existed. Much as this is not a licence for uncritical feeling, it means the narrow empiricist position — that only verifiable claims deserve credence — is thought to be inconsistent with the actual practice of science. Science itself uses forms of knowledge that exceed what can be immediately proved.
C.  Intuition is believed to have no legitimate role in scientific knowledge, in that it seems to introduce bias and subjectivity that proper method is designed to eliminate.
Task 2 — Notes

What We Know Without Proof — Listening Notes

1. Positivism: “The claim that only verifiable propositions are meaningful is itself ______.” “Logical positivism is thought to have ______ partly for this reason.”
2. Tacit knowledge: “We know ______ than we can tell.” “Tacit knowledge ... is known to underpin most ______ performance.”
3. Beauty: “The phenomenological reality — the experience itself — is known to ______.” “The experience of beauty is known to have effects on wellbeing, ______, and meaning.”
4. Meaning: “Human beings are known to need a sense that their lives ______.” “But meaning cannot be ______ in the way a physical constant can.”
5. Intuition: “Scientific discovery is known to depend on ______ as well as method.” “Many major breakthroughs are said to have begun with a ______ that something was true before the proof existed.”
Task 3 — Critical Evaluation
1.  Dr. Wren says the narrow empiricist position is thought to be inconsistent with the actual practice of science. Much as science is thought to be the model of rigorous knowledge, does this argument undermine science — or does it expand what science is? Use Complex Subject.
_______________________________________________
2.  Dr. Osei says a person who only trusts what can be proved is “blind to a large class of real knowledge.” What is this class? Use in that and Complex Subject.
_______________________________________________

Handout 5

Speaking

Speaking
Discussion
1.The article says tacit knowledge is thought to be the most reliable knowledge in many domains. Can you think of a skill or area of expertise where you know things you cannot fully explain? What is this knowledge like?
2.The article says meaning is known through living, not through experiment. Much as this is not a scientific claim, do you find it convincing? What forms of knowledge are known to come only through experience?
3.Dr. Osei says a person who only accepts what can be proved is “not more rational — they are simply blind to a large class of real knowledge.” Is this fair? Can you think of someone who holds this position? What does it miss, and what does it protect against?
🔥  Debate
🔥 “A person who only accepts what can be proved is not more rational — they are simply blind to a large class of real knowledge.”

Rules: Two teams. 4 minutes each. 1+ Complex Subject + 1 much as + 1 vocabulary term.

🟢  FOR — Proof is not enough Tacit knowledge is thought to underpin most of what experts actually know. Beauty is known to have effects that science cannot fully explain. Meaning is believed to be the most important determinant of long-term wellbeing, yet it cannot be verified. Much as proof is a powerful tool, it is known to be insufficient for the forms of knowledge that matter most.
🔴  AGAINST — Proof is the safeguard Intuition is known to have led people to false conclusions as often as true ones. Much as tacit knowledge is real, it is also said to be the source of systematic bias and error. The history of human belief is thought to show that feelings of certainty about unprovable things have produced more harm than good. Proof is not the only form of knowledge — but it is the only reliable check on the others.

Handout 6

Writing

Writing
Writing Task

Choose one option. 250–300 words. 3+ Complex Subject structures + 3 vocab + 1 much as + 1 in that.

Option A — Analytical: Evaluate the article’s argument that “the claim that only provable things deserve belief risks closing off access to the forms of knowledge that matter most.” Use Complex Subject to present the evidence, and much as to acknowledge the counter-argument.

Option B — Argumentative: “A person who only accepts what can be proved is not more rational — they are simply blind to a large class of real knowledge.” (Dr. Osei) Argue for or against. Use at least three Complex Subject structures and in that to specify your most important claim.

Option C — Applied: Choose one form of non-provable knowledge: tacit knowledge, intuition, the experience of beauty, or the sense of meaning. Analyse what makes it a genuine form of knowledge, and what makes it different from mere feeling or opinion. Use Complex Subject throughout, and much as to acknowledge the limits.
Must include: THREE Complex Subject structures  ·  THREE vocab  ·  ONE much as  ·  ONE in that  ·  250–300 words
Self-check:  [ ] 3+ Complex Subject (is thought to / believed to / known to / said to / seems to)  [ ] 1 much as  [ ] 1 in that  [ ] 3 vocab  [ ] 250–300 words