🌱 SEL Connection
Competencies: Self-Awareness · Self-Management · Resilience · Responsible Decision-MakingAt B2–C1, the lesson examines the psychological mechanisms. Brené Brown: perfectionism is a shield against shame — not about high standards, but about avoiding criticism. The procrastination link: not starting keeps the work hypothetically perfect. Self-criticism (paradoxically) makes it worse. Self-compassion (Neff) is the counter-intuitive solution. Gerunds + Infinitives are embedded throughout — the grammar of perfectionism.
📚 Research (Teacher Only)
Brené Brown ("The Gifts of Imperfection"): Perfectionism is not about excellence — it's a shield against shame. The belief: if I am perfect, I cannot be criticised. The problem: vulnerability and imperfection are what produce connection and creative output.
Kristin Neff (self-compassion): Self-compassion is associated with higher achievement motivation, not lower. Being harsh with yourself narrows thinking and reduces creativity. Counter-intuitive — and important to give students time to resist and process.
The procrastination link: The unwritten essay stays hypothetically perfect. Starting destroys that safety. Many procrastinators are perfectionists protecting themselves.
The core reframe: Perfectionism ≠ high standards. High standards are about the work. Perfectionism is about the person — the fear that imperfect work means you are imperfect. This conflation of work and identity is the mechanism.
The counter-intuitive finding: Self-compassion produces better results than self-criticism. Students often strongly resist this — they believe being hard on themselves is what keeps standards high. Give this time. The evidence is the point.
James's paradox (reading): His best piece was the one he submitted imperfectly, under external pressure. The perfectionist strategy designed to protect quality actually undermines it.
Grammar in context: Perfectionism is described entirely in gerund/infinitive structures: "Avoiding submitting anything" (gerund as subject) / "refusing to finish" (verb + inf.) / "stopping to check his email" vs "couldn't stop checking" (verb + both). Point these out in the reading before H2.
H1 Task B: 1. perfectionism 2. procrastination 3. paralysis 4. vulnerable 5. shame 6. striving 7. self-criticism 8. resilience 9. standard 10. threshold
H2 Find (in H3): Gerunds as subjects: "Avoiding submitting anything is not the same as producing excellent work." · "Having high standards is what he tells people." · Verb + both: "He stops to check his email" (pause to do) / "cannot stop checking" (finish checking) · Infinitive after adjective: "afraid to release"
H2 Ex 1: 1. to set 2. to finish 3. rewriting 4. starting 5. working 6. checking
H2 Verb+Both: a. stop checking = finish; stop to check = pause in order to · b. try submitting = experiment; try to submit = make an effort · c. remember making = recall past act; remember to hand in = don't forget future action
H3 T/F: 1T 2F (submitted under pressure, convinced it would damage his reputation) 3T 4F (tries working in different places — experiment with this, not eliminate the fear entirely) 5T
H3 Paradox: By refusing to submit imperfect work, James produces less — and the piece he is most proud of was the one he submitted imperfectly. The strategy designed to protect quality undermines it.
H4 T/F: 1T 2T 3F (self-compassion = higher achievement motivation, not lower) 4T
H4 Gap: 1. shame 2. starting 3. self-criticism 4. achievement motivation 5. threshold
Perfectionism
Vocabulary
Vocabulary · B2–C1Grammar
Grammar · B2–C1Read "The Submission" (Handout 3) and find:
a. Two gerunds used as subjects (e.g. "Submitting imperfect work is...")
b. One "verb + both" example — where the same verb takes gerund or infinitive with different meaning
c. One infinitive after an adjective (e.g. "afraid to...")
a. _______________________________________________________________
b. _______________________________________________________________
c. _______________________________________________________________
Verb + Gerund
Verb + Infinitive
⚠ Verb + Both — Different Meaning
Reading
Reading · B2–C1Listening
Listening · B2–C1First listen: Why does self-criticism make perfectionism worse, not better? Second listen: Complete the tasks.
Why is this counter-intuitive? What do most people believe about self-criticism — and what does the evidence actually show? Can you think of an example from your own experience?
Speaking
SpeakingSEL🌱 SEL Reflection — The Shield
Brené Brown: Perfectionism is not about excellence — it is a shield against shame. The belief: if I am perfect, criticism cannot reach me. The problem: vulnerability is precisely what produces connection and creative output.The paradox: Refusing to submit imperfect work produces less output — and, ironically, less quality. The perfect piece on the desktop serves nobody. James's best work was the one he submitted imperfectly.
The counter-intuitive solution: Self-compassion (Neff) produces higher achievement motivation than self-criticism. Being harsh with yourself narrows thinking and reduces creativity.
The threshold question: "Striving to do well" vs "refusing to finish." Both look the same from outside. The difference is in the motivation — and in what happens when something goes wrong.
Writing
Writing · B2–C1SELWrite 120–150 words. At least four vocabulary words, three gerund/infinitive structures (including one verb + both pair), formal register.

