G1 verb phrases: tends to · appears to · would seem to · is likely to · suggests that
G2 modal adverbs: arguably · may well · to some extent · broadly speaking
G3 evidential noun phrases: the evidence suggests · research indicates · one interpretation is that
20% of workers globally were engaged in 2025. 64% were “not engaged” (quiet quitting). 16% were actively disengaged. Gallup estimates that low engagement cost the global economy about $10 trillion in lost productivity (2026 report). The figure peaked at 23% in 2022–2023 and fell to 20% in 2025.
Gallup analysis: approximately 70% of the variance in team engagement is attributable to manager behaviour. This places primary responsibility at the organisational level — specifically, in management development and selection. Key teaching point: most companies focus on salary and benefits; the data would seem to suggest that investing in manager quality produces a higher return.
Career: work as a path to advancement — status, progression, achievement.
Calling: work experienced as intrinsically fulfilling and socially significant. “Calling” orientation correlates most strongly with engagement and wellbeing, and appears to be partially independent of job title or salary level.
Workers can reshape their roles without changing title or employer. Task crafting: change the type or number of tasks. Relational crafting: change who you interact with. Cognitive crafting: change how you think about the purpose of your work. Research suggests job crafting can shift workers from “job” to “calling” orientation.
Intrinsic: driven by inherent interest or meaning. Extrinsic: salary, status, fear. The overjustification effect: extrinsic rewards can reduce intrinsic motivation. This explains why pay increases alone rarely improve engagement above a basic income threshold.
Hedging signals that a claim is not absolute. At C1, precise hedging is academically essential — it shows command of evidence. An unhedged claim in research discussion signals overconfidence or insufficient engagement with the data.
“Engagement tends to correlate with manager quality more than salary.”
“The data would seem to suggest that autonomy matters more than recognition alone.”
“Arguably, the manager is the single most important variable in engagement.”
“Job crafting may well be more effective than a salary increase for disengaged workers.”
“The evidence suggests that intrinsic motivation produces more durable engagement.”
“One interpretation is that quiet quitting reflects a management failure, not a generational shift.”
G2 modal adverbs: “arguably a management failure” · “to some extent, yes” · “may well oversimplify” · “arguably, offering a pay increase” · “may well have accelerated” · “broadly speaking”
G3 noun phrases: “the data would seem to suggest” · “the evidence suggests it can be cultivated” · “research indicates” · “the data consistently points to” · “one interpretation is that” · “the evidence points to”
Exercise 3 — sample answers: 1. Autonomy appears to support engagement. 2. One interpretation is that quiet quitting reflects dissatisfaction with management. 3. The evidence suggests that job crafting may improve engagement.
💼 Job Satisfaction
Vocabulary
Vocabularyintrinsic · extrinsic · benchmark · tenure · organisational
Grammar
GrammarHedging language signals that a claim is not absolute. It acknowledges uncertainty, limits the scope, or marks the speaker’s confidence level. At C1, precise hedging is academically essential — it shows you engage with evidence rather than assert things without qualification.
“Engagement tends to correlate with manager quality more than salary level.”
“The data would seem to suggest that autonomy matters more than recognition alone.”
“A calling orientation appears to produce the most durable wellbeing outcomes.”
tends to / appears to / would seem to / is likely to + base verb · suggests + that + clause
“Arguably, the manager is the single most important variable in team engagement.”
“Job crafting may well be more effective than a salary increase for disengaged workers.”
“To some extent, job satisfaction is a personal responsibility as well as an organisational one.”
“The evidence suggests that intrinsic motivation produces more durable engagement.”
“One interpretation is that quiet quitting reflects a management failure, not a generational shift.”
“Research indicates that job crafting can shift workers toward a calling orientation.”
Reading
ReadingThe Engagement Gap
The Gallup State of the Global Workplace Report surveys workers across more than 160 countries. Its central finding — that 20% of the global workforce was engaged in 2025 — would seem to reflect something more structural than a temporary response to economic conditions. The global figure reached 23% in 2022–2023 but declined to 20% by 2025, suggesting persistent challenges despite year-to-year changes.
What the categories mean
Gallup divides workers into three groups. Engaged employees are enthusiastic and committed; they give discretionary effort — more than their job description requires. Not-engaged employees do the minimum; they are present but not invested. Actively disengaged employees are unhappy and, the data suggests, actively undermine their colleagues’ efforts. The last category tends to cost organisations significantly in attrition, absenteeism, and reduced productivity.
What research indicates about causation
Gallup’s own analysis suggests that approximately 70% of the variance in team engagement is attributable to manager behaviour. This would seem to place primary responsibility at the organisational level. However, research on calling orientation indicates that individual workers can hold very different relationships to the same role: one may experience it as a job, another as a calling. This orientation appears to be partially independent of management quality.
The salary question
Perhaps the most counterintuitive finding is that salary is arguably not the primary driver of engagement. The data tends to show that above a basic income threshold, autonomy, recognition, and clarity of purpose are stronger predictors. This may well reflect what Self-Determination Theory calls the overjustification effect: extrinsic rewards can, in some contexts, undermine intrinsic motivation.
One interpretation of the recent fall to 20% is that it reflects a systemic deficit in management quality. Another is that the proportion of people with a calling orientation is simply limited — and that organisations can, at best, create conditions in which that orientation is more likely to develop. The evidence does not yet resolve this question, but research on job crafting tends to suggest that the boundary between these two accounts is more permeable than it might initially appear.
Listening
ListeningThe Engagement Question — Key Points
Speaking
SpeakingDiscuss in groups. Use evidence from the reading and listening. Include at least two hedging structures in each contribution.
Writing
WritingOption A — Analytical (B2–C1): Analyse the Gallup finding that 70% of engagement variance is attributable to manager behaviour. What does this imply for organisations? What does it leave unexplained?
Option B — Argumentative (C1): “Job satisfaction is primarily a personal responsibility, not an organisational one.” Evaluate this claim using evidence from the lesson.
Option C — Opinion (C1): Is “quiet quitting” a reasonable response to poor management, or an abdication of personal responsibility? Give your reasoned opinion, acknowledging the complexity.
Word count: 250–300 words

