Psychologists David Dunning and Justin Kruger (Cornell University, 1999) ran four studies asking participants to rate their own ability in logic, grammar, and humour, then compared their self-ratings to their actual test scores. The finding: the lowest-performing participants consistently overestimated their performance and their rank relative to others. Crucially, they also failed to recognise genuine competence when they saw it in others. Dunning and Kruger’s explanation: the skills needed to perform well at a task are the same skills needed to recognise good performance — metacognitive ability and task competence are linked.
Zone 2 — Learning (the valley): You know a little more. Now you see how much you don’t know. You feel uncertain and less confident.
Zone 3 — Competent: You know a lot. You also know there is always more to learn. You feel moderately confident.
Zone 4 — Expert: You know a great deal. You are very aware of the limits of your knowledge. You feel appropriately humble — and appropriately confident.
These modals express the speaker’s logical deduction or estimate of probability — not obligation or permission. They are the grammar of thinking about what you know and what others know.
“She studies every day. She must find it difficult.”
“I must be good at this — I always get the answers right.” ← Dunning-Kruger thinking
Topic connection: must is the grammar of false confidence — “I must know this” when you actually don’t.
“He might be better at this than he thinks.”
“I might not be as good as I think I am.” ← healthy self-doubt
Topic connection: might is the grammar of honest uncertainty — exactly what beginners lack.
“She can’t be an expert — she made basic mistakes.”
“I can’t understand everything about this topic in one lesson.”
Topic connection: can’t is the grammar of logical limits — what is not possible given the evidence.
“You must study” = obligation (you have to) ≠ “She must be good” = deduction (I conclude she is)
“He can’t come” = permission/ability ≠ “He can’t know much” = deduction (I conclude he doesn’t)
Context tells you which meaning is intended.
Answer Key
The Dunning-Kruger Effect
Vocabulary
VocabularyMatch each situation to a word from Part A.
Use the words from Part A.
Grammar
GrammarWe use these modals to say what we think is logically true — based on what we know. This is different from must = obligation (“you must study”) or can’t = ability (“I can’t swim”).
“She studies every day. She must find it very difficult.”
“I always get the right answer. I must be good at this.” ← (Dunning-Kruger thinking!)
Form: subject + must + infinitive (no to, no -s)
× “She must knows a lot.” ✓ “She must know a lot.”
“He might be better at this than he thinks.”
“I might not be as good as I think I am.” ← (healthy self-doubt)
Form: subject + might (not) + infinitive
× “She might be not right.” ✓ “She might not be right.”
“She made basic mistakes. She can’t be an expert.”
“I can’t understand everything after one lesson.”
Form: subject + can’t + infinitive
× “Cann’t” ✓ “Can’t” (one word, one n)
Zone 1 (beginner): “I must know this topic well.” ← overconfidence
Zone 2 (learning): “I might not know as much as I thought.” ← honest doubt
Zone 3 (expert): “I can’t be sure about everything in this area.” ← informed humility
Look at the facts. Write what you can conclude using must, might, or can’t.
Some uses of must and can’t show deduction; others show obligation or ability. Which is which?
Reading
ReadingThe Quiz Champion
Leo loved quiz games. He played them online every weekend. He always scored well in music and film. His friends called him “the quiz champion.”
One afternoon, his friend set up a quiz competition. There were five rounds: music, film, science, history, and geography. Leo felt very confident. “I must be one of the best players here,” he thought. “I know so much about music and film.”
Round 1 — Music: Leo got 9 out of 10. He must know a lot about music — he was right about that.
Round 2 — Film: Leo got 8 out of 10. Still good.
Round 3 — Science: Leo got 3 out of 10. He didn’t feel worried. “Science might not be my best subject.”
Round 4 — History: Leo got 2 out of 10. He answered quickly but got most answers wrong.
Round 5 — Geography: Leo got 1 out of 10. He answered every single question with confidence. Every answer was wrong.
After the quiz, Leo was quiet. He thought he knew geography. He answered quickly and confidently. But he got almost everything wrong. He didn’t feel uncertain. He felt sure — and he was wrong.
His friend — who studied geography at school — smiled. “The problem can’t be your memory,” she said. “You remembered things. But you remembered wrong things. The real problem is this: you didn’t know what you didn’t know. You thought you were right. That is the hardest kind of wrong.”
Leo thought about this. “So I must know music well — that explains my score. And in geography — I didn’t know enough to feel uncertain. So I felt confident. And I was completely wrong.”
Leo looked at his score sheet again. Music: 9. Geography: 1. He felt confident about the music score. And now — for the first time — he felt genuinely uncertain about everything else.
His friend said: “That feeling of uncertainty — that might be the most important thing you learned today.”
Listening
ListeningJosh’s Presentation — Key Points
Listen again. Find examples of each modal used for deduction.
Speaking
SpeakingChoose one subject or skill. Rate your ability from 1 to 10. Then discuss with your partner.
Writing
WritingOption A — Personal: Describe a time when you felt confident about something but later realised you were wrong, or didn’t know as much as you thought. What did you learn?
Option B — Analytical: “The most dangerous thing is not making mistakes — it is not knowing that you make them.” Do you agree? Use ideas from the lesson.
Option C — Opinion: How can schools help students develop more honest self-assessment? Give at least two practical recommendations.
Word count: 80–100 words
must at least once · might / might not at least once · can’t at least once · at least 4 vocabulary words from Handout 1

