🌱 SEL Connection — B2–C1
Competencies: Self-Awareness · Responsible Decision-MakingAt B2–C1, the lesson moves beyond the basic claim ("you know yourself best") to examine its psychological mechanism: the difference between external validation and internal standards. Cleft sentences are the grammar of emphasis and focus — "It is you who decides." "What you need is not more opinions, but greater clarity." The grammar enacts the argument: it shifts emphasis onto the right subject, the right need, the right source of authority.
📚 Research Notes (Teacher Only)
Bandura's self-efficacy: The belief in one's capacity to execute the behaviours necessary to achieve specific outcomes. External validation can contribute to self-efficacy — but only when it is informative (specific feedback on performance) rather than evaluative (general approval of the person). The problem is not seeking feedback; it is when feedback becomes a substitute for internal standards rather than an input to them.
Feedback vs verdict: Feedback is specific, task-focused, and instrumental — "This section is less clear than the previous one." Verdict is global, person-focused, and terminal — "You are talented / not good enough." People who seek verdicts rather than feedback develop external calibration; people who seek feedback develop internal calibration. The former is more immediately comforting; the latter builds genuine self-knowledge.
The approval trap: Seeking approval creates a dependency loop — the action that generates approval becomes more frequent; the internal sense of what is good or right atrophies. Over time, the person loses access to their own criteria and can only evaluate their work by reference to others' reactions. Grace's story illustrates this trajectory.
Why cleft for this topic: The cleft sentence does one thing exceptionally well — it isolates and emphasises a single element of a clause. "It is you who decides" says: not them, not the circumstances, not the approval — you. The grammar enacts the lesson's central argument. At C1, students should be using this structure in their own analytical writing.
IT-cleft vs WH-cleft: IT-cleft emphasises a specific element (who/what/when/where): "It was the question that exposed the gap." WH-cleft emphasises the predicate (what something is): "What she lacked was not confidence but a benchmark." They have different pragmatic functions — IT-cleft contrasts; WH-cleft defines.
The reading strategy: Ask students to find every cleft structure in the Grace text before doing the grammar lesson. They will find the grammar embedded in the SEL content — this is the goal: the structure and the argument are inseparable.
Answer Key
H1 Task B: 1. validate 2. external 3. internal 4. benchmark 5. criterion 6. authority 7. esteem 8. calibrate 9. verdict 10. scrutiny
H2 Find in H3: IT-cleft: "It was the question 'What do you think?' that stopped her." / "It is not the absence of uncertainty that distinguishes a reliable self-judge." WH-cleft: "What she had cultivated was an exquisite sensitivity to others' reactions." / "What she lacked was not intelligence or professional skill, but an internal benchmark." / "What she needed was not more positive feedback, but a criterion that was her own."
H2 Ex 1: 1. It is your own experience that gives you authority. 2. It was the question that changed everything. 3. It is you who decides. 4. It was not praise that motivated her, but clarity.
H2 Ex 2: 1. What she needed was a benchmark, not approval. 2. What external input provides is data. 3. What distinguishes feedback from verdict is the direction — person or task? 4. What the approval trap creates is dependency, not knowledge.
H2 Ex 3: Students transform neutral sentences into clefts. Check: IT-cleft changes emphasis; WH-cleft defines/focuses the predicate.
H3 T/F: 1T 2F (Grace had no internal benchmark — she could not evaluate her own work without external input) 3T 4F (she did not know — she had never been asked this) 5T
H4 T/F: 1T 2T 3F (it is the direction, not the quantity, that matters — whether input flows into your judgment or replaces it) 4T
H4 Gap: 1. verdict 2. feedback 3. authority / internal 4. calibrate 5. benchmark
You Are Your Own Best Judge
Vocabulary
Vocabulary · B2–C1Grammar
Cleft SentencesRead "The Question" (Handout 3) and find:
a. Two IT-cleft sentences ("It is/was + X + that/who...")
→ _______________________________________________
b. Two WH-cleft sentences ("What + clause + is/was + X")
→ _______________________________________________
Emphasis on element
Moves the focus element to a prominent position. Implies contrast: this, not something else.
"It is you who decides." (not them)
"It was the question that stopped her." (not the answer)
"It was not praise that she needed, but a criterion." (contrast)
Defines the predicate
Defines what something is or what someone needs/lacks. Less contrastive than IT-cleft; more definitional.
"What you need is not more opinions, but greater clarity."
"What others provide is data, not a verdict."
"What she lacked was not skill, but an internal benchmark."
Predicate first
The reversed form of the WH-cleft. Fronts the predicate for added emphasis. Formal/literary register.
"Data is what others provide." (≈ "What others provide is data.")
"A criterion of your own is what she was building."
Transform each sentence into an IT-cleft to emphasise the underlined element.
Transform each sentence into a WH-cleft beginning with "What".
Rewrite each statement using a cleft sentence of your choice. Explain which type you used and why.
Reading
Reading · B2–C1Using vocabulary from H1 and at least one cleft sentence, explain what internal criteria are, where they come from, and why they matter for self-judgment.→ _______________________________________________
Listening
Listening · B2–C1First listen: What is the difference between feedback and verdict? Second listen: Complete the tasks below.
Speaking
SpeakingSEL🌱 SEL Reflection — The Research
Bandura's self-efficacy: External validation contributes to self-efficacy in the short term. But what mastery experiences build is durable internal calibration. It is internal criteria — developed through effort and reflection — that produce the most stable self-knowledge.Feedback vs verdict: What feedback provides is information you can integrate into your own assessment. What a verdict provides is identity confirmation — and it creates dependency. It is the feedback-seeker who develops internal judgment; it is the verdict-seeker who loses it.
The approval trap: What external validation creates, over time, is a standard that fluctuates with others' reactions. What internal criteria provide is stability. It is not that external input is useless — it is that it must flow into your judgment, not replace it.
The grammar: Cleft sentences isolate what matters. "It is you who decides." "What you need is not more opinions, but greater clarity." Use them when you want to foreground the essential element in an argument.
Writing
WritingSELWrite 120–150 words. At least four vocabulary words, three cleft sentences (at least one IT-cleft and one WH-cleft), formal register.

