(1) Agglomeration: Notwithstanding the logic of spreading production to where it is cheapest, firms cluster near other firms (shared suppliers, labour pools, knowledge spillovers). Cities become disproportionately productive. Silicon Valley, London’s financial district, and Shenzhen’s manufacturing zone all show this. Once established, clusters are self-reinforcing. (2) Value chain: Notwithstanding producing most physical goods, developing countries capture little of the final value precisely because the highest-return activities cluster in wealthy countries. The “smile curve” shows this: design and R&D (high value) — manufacturing (low value) — marketing and branding (high value). (3) Resource curse: Notwithstanding resource wealth, many resource-rich states fail to develop. Dutch disease, rentier dynamics, and institutional atrophy all contribute.
“Notwithstanding its vast oil reserves, Nigeria remains one of the poorest countries per capita.”
“Notwithstanding decades of globalisation, the gap between rich and poor countries has not closed.”
“Notwithstanding high commodity prices, resource-dependent economies rarely achieve sustained development.”
“Notwithstanding their commitment to free trade, rich countries frequently use protectionism.”
notwithstanding + V-ing:
“Notwithstanding producing most of the world’s physical goods, developing countries capture only a fraction of the value.”
“Notwithstanding receiving significant foreign investment, the country failed to develop domestic industries.”
× “Notwithstanding the country is rich in oil” → ✓ “Notwithstanding its oil wealth”
⚠ Compare with “despite” / “in spite of” (same meaning, less formal):
“Despite its oil reserves” = “Notwithstanding its oil reserves” (more formal, more analytical)
⚠ Position: almost always sentence-initial. The gap between expectation and reality is the core move:
“Notwithstanding [what you would expect], [what actually happens].”
Answer Key
Why Wealth Clusters
Vocabulary
Vocabulary“The poor stay poor, the rich get rich — that’s how it goes. Everybody knows.”
Leonard Cohen, Everybody Knows (1988)Fill in the correct term. Each sentence uses notwithstanding.
Grammar
GrammarUse notwithstanding + noun or V-ing to mark a concession — to say that something is true despite an obstacle or contrary expectation. The core move: [what you would expect] vs [what actually happens].
“Notwithstanding its vast oil reserves, Nigeria remains one of the poorest countries per capita.”
“Notwithstanding decades of globalisation, the gap between rich and poor countries has not closed.”
“Notwithstanding high commodity prices, resource-dependent economies rarely achieve sustained development.”
“Notwithstanding their commitment to free trade, rich countries frequently use protectionism.”
notwithstanding + V-ing:
“Notwithstanding producing most of the world’s physical goods, developing countries capture only a fraction of the value.”
“Notwithstanding receiving significant foreign investment, the country failed to develop domestic industries.”
× “Notwithstanding the country is rich in oil” → ✓ “Notwithstanding its oil wealth”
⚠ Compare with “despite” / “in spite of” (same meaning, less formal):
“Despite its oil reserves, Nigeria remains poor.” (neutral)
“Notwithstanding its oil reserves, Nigeria remains poor.” (formal, analytical)
⚠ The key move: expectation gap:
“Notwithstanding [what should produce result X], [the opposite / something unexpected happens].”
Complete logically with notwithstanding + noun or V-ing.
Rewrite using notwithstanding to make the concession more formal and analytical.
Three notwithstanding sentences about trade, wealth, or economic geography.
“Norway managed its oil wealth by virtue of having strong democratic institutions and a competent civil service before the oil arrived — notwithstanding the resource curse that affected other oil states.”
“The resource curse is so persistent precisely because resource income removes the need for taxation, which removes the pressure to represent citizens, which results in institutional atrophy.”
“The resource curse is thought to operate through multiple mechanisms — Dutch disease, rentier dynamics, and institutional atrophy — notwithstanding the obvious potential of resource wealth to fund development.”
Reading
ReadingWhy Wealth Clusters
Agglomeration and the winner-takes-most economy
Trade theory predicts that production should spread to wherever it is cheapest, resulting in convergence between rich and poor countries. Notwithstanding this prediction, wealth has consistently clustered. Cities like London, Singapore, and San Francisco are known to produce disproportionate shares of global economic output, notwithstanding occupying a tiny fraction of the world’s land and population. This is the agglomeration effect: by virtue of concentrating firms, talent, infrastructure, and institutional knowledge, successful economic clusters attract further investment and produce self-reinforcing advantages. The firms at the centre of a cluster gain access to specialised suppliers, skilled workers, and knowledge spillovers that firms elsewhere cannot replicate. Notwithstanding higher costs, they remain more competitive.
The value chain paradox
Notwithstanding producing most of the world’s physical goods, developing countries capture only a small fraction of the final value. This is known as the value chain paradox, and it results from the concentration of high-return activities — design, software, finance, and brand management — in wealthy countries by virtue of their institutional advantages, intellectual property regimes, and access to capital. The “smile curve” of value distribution illustrates this: the highest value concentrates at the two ends (research and design; marketing and sales) and the lowest value sits in the middle (manufacturing and assembly). Notwithstanding the labour and physical effort they contribute, countries in the manufacturing middle consistently earn less than those at the high-value ends.
The resource curse
Notwithstanding its apparent logic — that natural wealth results in national wealth — resource abundance is thought to correlate with slower economic development in many cases. Nigeria, Venezuela, and Angola all possess vast oil reserves and remain among the poorest countries per capita. The mechanisms are well documented: Dutch disease results in currency appreciation that makes other exports uncompetitive. The rentier state results in a government that taxes resources rather than citizens, removing the incentive to represent them. Notwithstanding the windfall, institutions atrophy and the economy fails to diversify. The exceptions are instructive: Norway and Botswana both managed their resource wealth successfully, by virtue of having strong, accountable institutions before the resources arrived. The lesson is not that resources are always a curse. It is that institutions determine whether resources result in prosperity or dependency.
Listening
ListeningThe Geography of Wealth — Key Points
Speaking
SpeakingRules: Two teams. 4 minutes each. 1+ notwithstanding + 1 Complex Subject + 1 vocabulary term.
Writing
WritingChoose one option. 250–300 words. 3+ notwithstanding + 3 vocab + 1 Complex Subject + 1 review structure.
Option B — Argumentative: “Notwithstanding its apparent windfall, natural resource wealth frequently results in slower development rather than faster. The resource curse is structural, not accidental.” Argue for or against. Use notwithstanding to mark the key paradoxes.
Option C — Applied: Choose one country. Analyse its position in the global value chain. Notwithstanding its geographic or resource advantages (or disadvantages), what determines whether it benefits from trade? Use by virtue of and precisely because.

