אוסף אמין שנבנה מתוך ניסיון כיתתי עשיר על ידי שני מורים פעילים בהוראת אנגלית.

זה עובד. זה בדוק. פשוט, קל ובחינם.

Economic Geography · Trade · Agglomeration · Resource Curse · B2–C1
Teacher’s Lesson Plan — B2–C1
Confidential 📄 Handouts →
Lesson Overview
Topic
Three paradoxes of economic geography: (1) Agglomeration — notwithstanding the theoretical efficiency of spreading production evenly, wealth clusters and self-reinforces. (2) The value chain paradox — notwithstanding producing most of the world’s physical goods, developing countries capture only a fraction of the value. (3) The resource curse — notwithstanding vast natural wealth, resource-rich states often fail to develop. In each case, the structure (not the people) is responsible for the outcome.
Central question
“Notwithstanding decades of global trade growth, wealth consistently clusters rather than spreads. What does this tell us about how trade actually works — as opposed to how economists say it should?”
Level
B2–C1
Duration
90 minutes
Grammar ★
notwithstanding + noun / V-ing (NEW C1 star) — “Notwithstanding its vast oil reserves, Nigeria remains one of the poorest countries per capita.” / “Notwithstanding decades of globalisation, wealth has not spread as trade theory predicts.” / “Notwithstanding producing most of the world’s physical goods, developing countries capture only a small share of the value.” Meaning: despite; in spite of; regardless of. C1 formal, concessive. Marks the gap between what should happen and what actually does. Perfect for economic paradoxes.
Grammar in texts
Complex Subject throughout; notwithstanding (8+); by virtue of (review); precisely because (review).
H2 review
by virtue of + noun/V-ing: write two sentences. precisely because + clause: write two sentences. Complex Subject: write four sentences about trade, wealth, or economic geography.
Characters
Dr. Layla Hassan (46) & Dr. David Osei (44)
Key concepts
agglomeration · comparative advantage · commodity · value chain · rentier state · protectionism · multiplier effect · terms of trade · remittance · Dutch disease
Debate
H5: “Notwithstanding the theoretical case for free trade, it consistently results in greater benefits for already-wealthy countries. Protectionism is a legitimate development strategy.”
Writing
250–300 words · 3+ notwithstanding · 3 vocab · 1 Complex Subject · 1 review structure
Background
Three paradoxes

(1) Agglomeration: Notwithstanding the logic of spreading production to where it is cheapest, firms cluster near other firms (shared suppliers, labour pools, knowledge spillovers). Cities become disproportionately productive. Silicon Valley, London’s financial district, and Shenzhen’s manufacturing zone all show this. Once established, clusters are self-reinforcing. (2) Value chain: Notwithstanding producing most physical goods, developing countries capture little of the final value precisely because the highest-return activities cluster in wealthy countries. The “smile curve” shows this: design and R&D (high value) — manufacturing (low value) — marketing and branding (high value). (3) Resource curse: Notwithstanding resource wealth, many resource-rich states fail to develop. Dutch disease, rentier dynamics, and institutional atrophy all contribute.

The exceptions are instructive: Norway (oil managed well by virtue of strong pre-existing institutions), Botswana (diamonds, same reason), South Korea (no resources, success by virtue of deliberate industrial policy). The lesson: institutions and political choices determine whether geographic conditions result in prosperity.
Key Grammar — notwithstanding + noun / V-ing
notwithstanding + noun:
“Notwithstanding its vast oil reserves, Nigeria remains one of the poorest countries per capita.”
“Notwithstanding decades of globalisation, the gap between rich and poor countries has not closed.”
“Notwithstanding high commodity prices, resource-dependent economies rarely achieve sustained development.”
“Notwithstanding their commitment to free trade, rich countries frequently use protectionism.”

notwithstanding + V-ing:
“Notwithstanding producing most of the world’s physical goods, developing countries capture only a fraction of the value.”
“Notwithstanding receiving significant foreign investment, the country failed to develop domestic industries.”
⚠  Noun or V-ing required (not a clause):
× “Notwithstanding the country is rich in oil” → ✓ “Notwithstanding its oil wealth”

⚠  Compare with “despite” / “in spite of” (same meaning, less formal):
“Despite its oil reserves” = “Notwithstanding its oil reserves” (more formal, more analytical)

⚠  Position: almost always sentence-initial. The gap between expectation and reality is the core move:
“Notwithstanding [what you would expect], [what actually happens].”
Lesson Procedure
Time
Stage
Skill
Teacher does
Students do
0–8
Hook
Speaking
“Complete: ‘Notwithstanding decades of global trade, wealth has…’” Collect. Then: “What do you expect trade to do to inequality? What does it actually do?”
Complete. Discuss.
8–20
H1 Vocab
Vocab
10 terms. All examples use notwithstanding and review structures. Key: agglomeration, value chain, Dutch disease, terms of trade, rentier state.
Study. Match. Fill.
20–38
H2 Grammar
Grammar
notwithstanding: noun/V-ing, not clause; compare “despite/in spite of”; sentence-initial; marks expectation gap. Review: by virtue of (write 2). Review: precisely because (write 2). Complex Subject: write 4.
Study. Exercises.
38–57
H3 Reading
Reading
‘Why Wealth Clusters.’ T/F/NG + 4 analytical questions.
Read. Tasks.
57–70
H4 Listening
Listening
Dr. Hassan & Dr. Osei. Read TWICE. MCQ + Notes + Task 3.
MCQ. Notes.
70–80
H5 Debate
Speaking
“Protectionism is a legitimate development strategy.” notwithstanding required.
Debate.
80–90
H6 Writing
Writing
250–300 words. 3+ notwithstanding + 3 vocab + 1 Complex Subject + 1 review structure.
Plan. Write.
Listening Script — ‘The Geography of Wealth’
Dr. Layla Hassan (46) & Dr. David Osei (44). notwithstanding (8+). Complex Subject (8+). by virtue of (3+). precisely because (3+). Read TWICE.
Layla:
David, I want to start with what strikes me as the central paradox of economic geography: wealth is supposed to spread through trade, but it consistently clusters instead. Notwithstanding decades of globalisation, the gap between the wealthiest and poorest countries has not converged in the way that simple trade theory predicts. Why?
David:
The agglomeration argument is the most convincing to me. By virtue of concentrating talent, capital, infrastructure, and institutional knowledge in one place, cities like London, Singapore, and San Francisco produce self-reinforcing advantages that result in further concentration rather than dispersal. Notwithstanding the theoretical efficiency of spreading production evenly, firms locate near other firms, skilled workers cluster near other skilled workers, and financial capital flows to where financial capital already exists. The result is winner-takes-most geography that free trade alone does not correct.
Layla:
The value chain argument is equally important. Notwithstanding producing most of the world’s physical goods, developing countries capture a fraction of the final value. Precisely because the highest-return activities — design, software, finance, branding — concentrate in wealthy countries by virtue of their institutional advantages, the countries that do the physical work receive the lowest share of what the product sells for. The terms of trade work against them: over time, commodity export prices rise more slowly than manufactured import prices, resulting in a steady deterioration in purchasing power.
David:
The resource curse is perhaps the starkest illustration. Notwithstanding vast oil wealth, countries like Nigeria, Venezuela, and Angola remain among the poorest per capita. Precisely because resource income flows to governments rather than through a productive economy, it results in what economists call the rentier state: a government that does not need to tax its citizens and therefore feels no pressure to represent them. Notwithstanding the windfall, institutions atrophy, manufacturing declines due to Dutch disease, and when the resource runs out, the economy has nothing to show for it.
Layla:
And yet the exceptions are instructive. Notwithstanding its lack of natural resources and its initially poor geography, South Korea transformed its economic position by virtue of deliberate industrial policy — protecting infant industries, investing in education, targeting specific sectors for development. Norway managed its oil wealth precisely because it had strong institutions before the oil arrived. Botswana managed its diamonds for the same reason. The lesson is not that geography is destiny, but that institutions and political choices determine whether geographic conditions result in prosperity or dependency.
notwithstanding (8+): “notwithstanding decades of globalisation” · “notwithstanding the theoretical efficiency of spreading production” · “notwithstanding producing most of the world’s physical goods” · “notwithstanding vast oil wealth” · “notwithstanding the windfall” · “notwithstanding its lack of natural resources” · “notwithstanding its initially poor geography”
Answer Key
H1 B: 1.agglomeration 2.comparative advantage 3.commodity 4.value chain 5.rentier state
H1 C: 1.protectionism 2.multiplier effect 3.terms of trade 4.remittance 5.Dutch disease
H3 T/F/NG: 1.T 2.T 3.F(article says institutions and political choices determine whether geography results in prosperity) 4.NG 5.T
H4 MCQ: 1.b 2.c 3.b

Why Wealth Clusters

Trade, Resources, and the Geography of Power — B2–C1 · 90 min
Name:  
Date:  
Class:  

Handout 1

Vocabulary

Vocabulary

“The poor stay poor, the rich get rich — that’s how it goes. Everybody knows.”

Leonard Cohen, Everybody Knows (1988)
Every example uses the grammar star: notwithstanding + noun / V-ing — despite; in spite of; marking the gap between what you would expect and what actually happens.
Term
Level
Definition
Example
agglomeration
C1
The clustering of economic activity in a particular place; here: why industries, talent, and capital tend to concentrate rather than spread evenly.
"Notwithstanding equal starting conditions, agglomeration effects result in wealth concentrating in a few cities — Silicon Valley, London, Singapore — precisely because proximity between firms, talent, and capital produces self-reinforcing advantages."
comparative advantage
C1
The ability of a country to produce a good at a lower opportunity cost than another; the theoretical basis for specialisation and trade.
"Notwithstanding its lack of natural resources, Singapore developed a comparative advantage in financial services and logistics — by virtue of its location, education system, and legal institutions."
commodity
C1
A raw material or primary product traded in bulk — oil, wheat, copper, cocoa; here: why commodity-dependent economies face structural vulnerability.
"Notwithstanding high commodity prices in boom years, commodity-dependent economies rarely result in sustained development — precisely because price volatility creates cycles of boom and bust that undermine long-term investment."
value chain
C1
The sequence of activities involved in bringing a product from raw material to final sale; here: who captures value at each stage and why.
"Notwithstanding producing most of the world’s physical goods, developing countries capture only a small share of the value chain — precisely because the highest-value stages (design, finance, branding) concentrate in wealthy countries."
rentier state
C1
A state that derives the majority of its revenue from exporting natural resources rather than from productive activity or taxation of its citizens.
"Notwithstanding its oil wealth, a rentier state often fails to develop diverse industries — precisely because resource income removes the pressure to tax citizens, which in turn removes the pressure to represent them."
protectionism
C1
The use of trade barriers — tariffs, quotas, subsidies — to protect domestic industries from foreign competition.
"Notwithstanding their commitment to free trade, rich countries frequently use protectionism to defend industries they consider strategic — precisely because the theoretical gains from free trade do not always match the political costs of deindustrialisation."
multiplier effect
C1
The process by which an initial increase in economic activity produces a larger final increase in output or income.
"Notwithstanding its small size, investment in infrastructure produces a significant multiplier effect — by virtue of lower transport costs and faster communication resulting in higher productivity across many sectors simultaneously."
terms of trade
C1
The ratio of a country’s export prices to its import prices; here: why countries that export commodities and import manufactured goods consistently lose purchasing power over time.
"Notwithstanding decades of growth in global trade volumes, the terms of trade for commodity exporters often deteriorate — precisely because the prices of raw materials rise more slowly than the prices of manufactured goods."
remittance
C1
Money sent by migrants to their home country; here: an often-overlooked financial flow that rivals foreign aid and investment in some economies.
"Notwithstanding the attention given to foreign direct investment, remittances result in larger financial inflows for many developing countries — by virtue of the sheer scale of global migration and the strong family ties that motivate sending."
Dutch disease
C1
The phenomenon whereby a boom in one sector of the economy (typically natural resources) results in the decline of other sectors, particularly manufacturing, through currency appreciation.
"Notwithstanding the apparent windfall of an oil discovery, Dutch disease results in manufacturing becoming uncompetitive — precisely because the influx of export revenue raises the currency, making other exports too expensive for foreign buyers."
Part B — Match
1.The clustering of economic activity in a particular place; why industries and talent concentrate rather than spread → _______________
2.The ability to produce a good at lower opportunity cost than another country; the theoretical basis for trade specialisation → _______________
3.A raw material or primary product traded in bulk — oil, wheat, copper; here: why commodity-dependent economies remain vulnerable → _______________
4.The sequence of activities from raw material to final sale; here: who captures value at each stage → _______________
5.A state deriving most revenue from natural resources rather than productive activity; here: why resource wealth often fails to develop economies → _______________
Part C — Fill in

Fill in the correct term. Each sentence uses notwithstanding.

protectionism  ·  multiplier effect  ·  terms of trade  ·  remittance  ·  Dutch disease
1.Notwithstanding their public commitment to free markets, most wealthy countries use some form of _______________ to protect strategic industries from foreign competition.
2.Notwithstanding its small initial scale, infrastructure investment produces a significant _______________ — by virtue of lower costs resulting in higher productivity across many sectors at once.
3.Notwithstanding growth in trade volumes, the _______________ for commodity exporters often deteriorate — precisely because raw material prices rise more slowly than those of manufactured goods.
4.Notwithstanding the attention given to foreign investment, _______________ flows to many developing countries exceed aid and rival direct investment — by virtue of the scale of global migration.
5.Notwithstanding an oil windfall, _______________ results in manufacturing declining precisely because the currency rises and makes other exports too expensive for foreign buyers.

Handout 2

Grammar

Grammar
★  Star Structure — notwithstanding + noun / V-ing

Use notwithstanding + noun or V-ing to mark a concession — to say that something is true despite an obstacle or contrary expectation. The core move: [what you would expect] vs [what actually happens].

notwithstanding + noun:
“Notwithstanding its vast oil reserves, Nigeria remains one of the poorest countries per capita.”
“Notwithstanding decades of globalisation, the gap between rich and poor countries has not closed.”
“Notwithstanding high commodity prices, resource-dependent economies rarely achieve sustained development.”
“Notwithstanding their commitment to free trade, rich countries frequently use protectionism.”

notwithstanding + V-ing:
“Notwithstanding producing most of the world’s physical goods, developing countries capture only a fraction of the value.”
“Notwithstanding receiving significant foreign investment, the country failed to develop domestic industries.”
⚠  Noun or V-ing required — NOT a clause:
× “Notwithstanding the country is rich in oil” → ✓ “Notwithstanding its oil wealth”

⚠  Compare with “despite” / “in spite of” (same meaning, less formal):
“Despite its oil reserves, Nigeria remains poor.” (neutral)
“Notwithstanding its oil reserves, Nigeria remains poor.” (formal, analytical)

⚠  The key move: expectation gap:
“Notwithstanding [what should produce result X], [the opposite / something unexpected happens].”
Exercise 1 — Complete

Complete logically with notwithstanding + noun or V-ing.

1.  _______________________________________________, the region remains one of the poorest in the world. (its abundant natural resources)
2.  _______________________________________________, the terms of trade for commodity exporters have deteriorated over the past decade. (the growth in global trade volumes)
3.  _______________________________________________, the city continues to attract investment and talent. (its extremely high cost of living)
4.  _______________________________________________, the country failed to develop a manufacturing sector. (receiving billions in foreign direct investment)
Exercise 2 — Transform

Rewrite using notwithstanding to make the concession more formal and analytical.

1.  “Despite its vast diamond wealth, Botswana managed to develop its economy successfully.”
→ _______________________________________________
2.  “Even though rich countries advocate for free trade, they protect their own agricultural sectors with subsidies.”
→ _______________________________________________
3.  “Although it produces 70% of the world’s cocoa, Ivory Coast captures very little of the profit from chocolate sales.”
→ _______________________________________________
Exercise 3 — Write your own

Three notwithstanding sentences about trade, wealth, or economic geography.

1.  _______________________________________________
2.  _______________________________________________
3.  _______________________________________________
▶  Review — by virtue of + noun/V-ing
“Notwithstanding its lack of natural resources, Singapore developed a comparative advantage in financial services and logistics by virtue of its strategic location, strong institutions, and investment in education.”
“Norway managed its oil wealth by virtue of having strong democratic institutions and a competent civil service before the oil arrived — notwithstanding the resource curse that affected other oil states.”
R1.  Write two by virtue of sentences about trade, comparative advantage, or economic development.
_______________________________________________
R2.  Complete: “Notwithstanding its geographic disadvantages, _______________________________________________by virtue of _______________________________________________”
_______________________________________________
▶  Review — precisely because + clause
“The value chain works against developing countries precisely because the highest-return activities — design, software, finance — concentrate in wealthy countries by virtue of their institutional advantages.”
“The resource curse is so persistent precisely because resource income removes the need for taxation, which removes the pressure to represent citizens, which results in institutional atrophy.”
R3.  Write two precisely because sentences about trade, agglomeration, or the resource curse.
_______________________________________________
R4.  Complete: “Notwithstanding rapid economic growth, inequality within developing countries often increases — precisely because _______________________________________________”
_______________________________________________
Grammar in Context — Complex Subject
“Agglomeration effects are believed to produce self-reinforcing advantages that result in winner-takes-most geography, notwithstanding the theoretical prediction that factor prices should equalise through trade.”
“The resource curse is thought to operate through multiple mechanisms — Dutch disease, rentier dynamics, and institutional atrophy — notwithstanding the obvious potential of resource wealth to fund development.”
1.  Write four sentences using Complex Subject about trade, agglomeration, or the resource curse.
1. _____ 2. _____ 3. _____ 4. _____
2.  Write four notwithstanding sentences about economic geography, trade, or global inequality.
1. _____ 2. _____ 3. _____ 4. _____

Handout 3

Reading

Reading
Economic Geography · Agglomeration · Value Chains · Resource Curse

Why Wealth Clusters

Reading · B2–C1

Agglomeration and the winner-takes-most economy

Trade theory predicts that production should spread to wherever it is cheapest, resulting in convergence between rich and poor countries. Notwithstanding this prediction, wealth has consistently clustered. Cities like London, Singapore, and San Francisco are known to produce disproportionate shares of global economic output, notwithstanding occupying a tiny fraction of the world’s land and population. This is the agglomeration effect: by virtue of concentrating firms, talent, infrastructure, and institutional knowledge, successful economic clusters attract further investment and produce self-reinforcing advantages. The firms at the centre of a cluster gain access to specialised suppliers, skilled workers, and knowledge spillovers that firms elsewhere cannot replicate. Notwithstanding higher costs, they remain more competitive.

“Notwithstanding decades of globalisation, wealth clusters rather than spreads. Understanding why is the central question of economic geography.”

The value chain paradox

Notwithstanding producing most of the world’s physical goods, developing countries capture only a small fraction of the final value. This is known as the value chain paradox, and it results from the concentration of high-return activities — design, software, finance, and brand management — in wealthy countries by virtue of their institutional advantages, intellectual property regimes, and access to capital. The “smile curve” of value distribution illustrates this: the highest value concentrates at the two ends (research and design; marketing and sales) and the lowest value sits in the middle (manufacturing and assembly). Notwithstanding the labour and physical effort they contribute, countries in the manufacturing middle consistently earn less than those at the high-value ends.

The resource curse

Notwithstanding its apparent logic — that natural wealth results in national wealth — resource abundance is thought to correlate with slower economic development in many cases. Nigeria, Venezuela, and Angola all possess vast oil reserves and remain among the poorest countries per capita. The mechanisms are well documented: Dutch disease results in currency appreciation that makes other exports uncompetitive. The rentier state results in a government that taxes resources rather than citizens, removing the incentive to represent them. Notwithstanding the windfall, institutions atrophy and the economy fails to diversify. The exceptions are instructive: Norway and Botswana both managed their resource wealth successfully, by virtue of having strong, accountable institutions before the resources arrived. The lesson is not that resources are always a curse. It is that institutions determine whether resources result in prosperity or dependency.

Task 1 — True, False, or Not Given?
1.  The article states that notwithstanding the prediction that production should spread, wealth has consistently clustered in a small number of cities.[ T / F / NG ]
2.  The article argues that the “smile curve” shows that manufacturing and assembly capture the lowest value in the production process.[ T / F / NG ]
3.  The article claims that geography alone determines whether resource wealth results in prosperity or dependency.[ T / F / NG ]
4.  The article names a specific financial instrument responsible for solving the resource curse in Norway.[ T / F / NG ]
5.  The article concludes that institutions determine whether resources result in prosperity or dependency, not the resources themselves.[ T / F / NG ]
Task 2 — Analysis
1.  The article says agglomeration effects result in self-reinforcing advantages, notwithstanding higher costs. How does this happen? Use by virtue of and notwithstanding.
_______________________________________________
2.  The article describes the “smile curve.” In your own words, explain what it shows. What does this mean for a country trying to move up the value chain?
_______________________________________________
3.  The article says the rentier state results in a government that has no incentive to represent citizens. What is the logic of this argument? Use precisely because.
_______________________________________________
4.  The article says Norway and Botswana succeeded by virtue of having strong institutions before the resources arrived. Does this mean poor institutions cause the resource curse, or does the resource curse cause poor institutions? Use notwithstanding.
_______________________________________________

Handout 4

Listening

Listening
Dr. Layla Hassan (46) and Dr. David Osei (44). Your teacher reads TWICE.
Task 1 — Multiple Choice
1.  What does Dr. Hassan say about the central paradox of economic geography?
A.  Notwithstanding decades of trade, all countries eventually converge to the same income level due to the spread of technology and capital.
B.  Wealth is supposed to spread through trade, but it consistently clusters instead. Notwithstanding decades of globalisation, the gap between the wealthiest and poorest countries has not converged in the way that simple trade theory predicts. Agglomeration effects result in winner-takes-most geography that free trade alone does not correct.
C.  Notwithstanding the clustering of wealth, most developing countries successfully attracted investment by virtue of lower wage costs, resulting in convergence with wealthy nations.
2.  What does Dr. Hassan say about the value chain paradox?
A.  Notwithstanding the low wages in manufacturing, developing countries benefit overall by virtue of the employment and skills that production generates.
B.  Notwithstanding producing most of the world’s physical goods, developing countries capture only a fraction of the final value. Precisely because the highest-return activities — design, software, finance, branding — concentrate in wealthy countries by virtue of their institutional advantages, the countries that do the physical work receive the lowest share of what the product sells for. The terms of trade work against them over time.
C.  The value chain paradox is thought to resolve itself over time, notwithstanding initial disadvantages, by virtue of technology transfer from wealthy to developing countries.
3.  What does Dr. Hassan say about the exceptions to the resource curse?
A.  Norway and Botswana succeeded notwithstanding their weak institutions, by virtue of strict regulations on resource extraction that prevented Dutch disease.
B.  Notwithstanding its lack of natural resources, South Korea transformed its position by virtue of deliberate industrial policy. Norway and Botswana managed resource wealth precisely because they had strong institutions before the resources arrived. The lesson is that institutions and political choices determine whether geographic conditions result in prosperity or dependency.
C.  The exceptions prove that notwithstanding the resource curse, discovering oil always results in eventual development if governments invest sufficiently in infrastructure.
Task 2 — Notes

The Geography of Wealth — Key Points

Agglomeration: notwithstanding theoretical prediction of _______________, wealth consistently _______________. By virtue of concentrating _______________, successful clusters produce _______________. Notwithstanding higher costs, firms in clusters remain more _______________. Result: winner-takes-most geography that _______________ alone does not correct.
Value chain: notwithstanding producing _______________, developing countries capture _______________. Precisely because highest-return activities _______________ concentrate in wealthy countries by virtue of _______________. Terms of trade: over time, commodity prices rise _______________ than manufactured goods prices, resulting in _______________.
Resource curse: notwithstanding apparent logic, resource abundance correlates with _______________. Mechanisms: Dutch disease results in _______________. Rentier state results in government that _______________, removing incentive to _______________. Notwithstanding the windfall, institutions _______________ and economy fails to _______________.
Exceptions: South Korea transformed its position by virtue of _______________. Norway and Botswana succeeded precisely because _______________. Lesson: _______________ determine whether geographic conditions result in prosperity or _______________.
Task 3 — Critical Evaluation
1.  Dr. Hassan says agglomeration results in winner-takes-most geography. Notwithstanding this, is there anything a country outside a major cluster can do? Use by virtue of and notwithstanding.
_______________________________________________
2.  Dr. Osei says South Korea succeeded by virtue of deliberate industrial policy. Notwithstanding this example, why do most countries that try the same strategy not succeed? Use precisely because.
_______________________________________________

Handout 5

Speaking

Speaking
Discussion
1.The article says wealth clusters notwithstanding the prediction that it should spread. Notwithstanding this clustering, do you think technology and the internet are changing where economic activity can locate? Give examples.
2.The article says the rentier state results in governments with no incentive to represent citizens. Notwithstanding the obvious appeal of resource income, why might a country that taxes its citizens for revenue govern them better?
3.Dr. Hassan says institutions determine whether resources result in prosperity or dependency. Notwithstanding the importance of institutions, do wealthy countries have any responsibility for the resource curse? Think about who buys the oil and who sells the mining equipment.
🔥  Debate
🔥 “Notwithstanding the theoretical case for free trade, it consistently results in greater benefits for already-wealthy countries. Protectionism is a legitimate development strategy.”

Rules: Two teams. 4 minutes each. 1+ notwithstanding + 1 Complex Subject + 1 vocabulary term.

🟢  FOR — Protectionism as strategy Notwithstanding the theoretical efficiency of free trade, its practical result is agglomeration that concentrates gains in countries already at the top. Precisely because infant industries need protection to develop comparative advantage, temporary protectionism is thought to be a necessary condition for catching up. South Korea and Taiwan used it successfully.
🔴  AGAINST — Free trade overall Notwithstanding its unequal distribution of gains, free trade results in lower prices, more choice, and access to global markets that protectionism forecloses. Precisely because protectionism often results in inefficiency and corruption rather than competitive industries, countries that try it mostly fail. The exceptions do not justify the rule.

Handout 6

Writing

Writing
Writing Task

Choose one option. 250–300 words. 3+ notwithstanding + 3 vocab + 1 Complex Subject + 1 review structure.

Option A — Analytical: Evaluate the claim that “notwithstanding decades of globalisation, wealth clusters rather than spreads.” Is agglomeration inevitable? Use notwithstanding, by virtue of, and precisely because to build the argument.

Option B — Argumentative: “Notwithstanding its apparent windfall, natural resource wealth frequently results in slower development rather than faster. The resource curse is structural, not accidental.” Argue for or against. Use notwithstanding to mark the key paradoxes.

Option C — Applied: Choose one country. Analyse its position in the global value chain. Notwithstanding its geographic or resource advantages (or disadvantages), what determines whether it benefits from trade? Use by virtue of and precisely because.
Must include: THREE notwithstanding  ·  THREE vocab  ·  ONE Complex Subject  ·  ONE by virtue of or precisely because
Self-check:  [ ] 3+ notwithstanding + noun/V-ing  [ ] 1 Complex Subject  [ ] 1 review structure  [ ] 3 vocab  [ ] 250–300 words