When researchers trapped, banded, and released a handful of American crows while wearing a distinctive mask, they created, in effect, three different populations of informed birds. Crows captured directly acquired their information firsthand, at real personal cost. Others, present at the scene but never captured themselves, seemed to learn simply by being conditioned to the commotion of the trapping event. A third group, never present at all and in some cases not yet born when the trapping occurred, nonetheless came to scold the same mask later — evidence of information passed horizontally between peers and vertically from parent to offspring.
Comparing how precisely each group of crows told the dangerous mask apart from a neutral one revealed a consistent pattern. Having acquired the information firsthand, directly captured birds discriminated between the two masks with the greatest precision. Crows informed only socially, having never been captured themselves, responded to the dangerous mask with real but somewhat less exact recognition. The transmission of the alarm, in other words, carried a genuine signal, but one with reduced fidelity compared with direct experience.
From an evolutionary standpoint, this trade-off makes sense. Being captured, however briefly and safely in this case, is a costly way to learn; a genuine predator encounter would be considerably more so. Cheap social information, even diluted in precision, still shifts the odds in a young or naive bird’s favour compared with having no information at all. Treated as a proxy for firsthand experience rather than a full substitute, socially transmitted alarm appears to be worth its imperfections.
The pattern is solid evidence that specific, usable information about a particular threat can spread through a crow population well beyond the individuals originally involved, including to naive offspring. It does not, on its own, establish deliberate teaching in a strict sense: the data are equally consistent with young birds picking up cues from adults’ alarm behaviour as they are with any intentional instruction. Vigilant caution is warranted before describing this capacity as crow “culture” in the fuller sense that term carries elsewhere in animal behaviour research. This tension motivates the True/False/Not Given task in Handout 3.
“Having acquired the information firsthand, directly captured birds discriminated between the two masks with the greatest precision.”
Present participle (-ing) — simultaneous reason or manner:
“Watching older birds mob the mask, naive crows appear to pick up at least a rough version of the association.”
Past participle (V3 alone) — passive circumstance:
“Tested years after the original trapping, individually informed crows still discriminated the dangerous mask with the greatest precision.”
Answer Key
Part B: 1. transmission · 2. precision · 3. diluted · 4. vigilant · 5. proxy · 6. discriminate · 7. costly · 8. firsthand · 9. fidelity · 10. trade-off
Part C: 1. proxy · 2. discriminate · 3. costly · 4. firsthand · 5. fidelity · 6. trade-off · 7. transmission · 8. precision · 9. diluted · 10. vigilant
Ex 1 (transform): Accept any version correctly forming a participle clause that preserves the original meaning.
Ex 2 (combine): Accept any grammatically correct participle-clause sentence combining the given facts.
T/F/NG: 1. T · 2. F (they did react, via conditioning to the trapping scene) · 3. F (socially informed crows discriminated less precisely, not more) · 4. NG · 5. T
Analysis: Q1: Because conditioning to the scene involves being physically present at the trapping event, while genuine social transmission involves crows that were never present at all, learning later from others. Q2: accept any well-reasoned answer using a participle clause. Q3: open evaluative question. Q4: open personal response.
MCQ: 1. B · 2. B · 3. B
Task 2 Notes: three · precisely · diluted · costly · culture
Task 3: open evaluative questions — assess reasoning quality and comprehension of the script, not a single fixed answer.
Cheap Information, Costly Accuracy
Vocabulary
VocabularyFill in the correct word.
Grammar
GrammarUse these structures to pack reason, time, or circumstance into a sentence without a second full clause.
“Having acquired the information firsthand, directly captured birds discriminated between the two masks with the greatest precision.”
Present participle (-ing) — simultaneous reason or manner:
“Watching older birds mob the mask, naive crows appear to pick up at least a rough version of the association.”
Past participle (V3 alone) — passive circumstance:
“Tested years after the original trapping, individually informed crows still discriminated the dangerous mask with the greatest precision.”
Rewrite each sentence using a participle clause.
Combine each pair into one sentence using a participle clause.
Three sentences of your own about a piece of important information — a warning, a rumour, a skill — that changed or lost some accuracy as it passed from person to person, compared with learning it firsthand. Use a participle clause at least twice.
Reading
ReadingCheap Information, Costly Accuracy: What Crows Reveal About Learning from Others
Three routes to the same alarm
When researchers trapped, banded, and released a handful of American crows while wearing a distinctive mask, they created, in effect, three different populations of informed birds. Crows captured directly acquired their information firsthand, at real personal cost. Others, present at the scene but never captured themselves, seemed to learn simply by being conditioned to the commotion of the trapping event. A third group, never present at all and in some cases not yet born when the trapping occurred, nonetheless came to scold the same mask later — evidence of information passed horizontally between peers and vertically from parent to offspring.
A cost that buys precision
Comparing how precisely each group of crows told the dangerous mask apart from a neutral one revealed a consistent pattern. Having acquired the information firsthand, directly captured birds discriminated between the two masks with the greatest precision. Crows informed only socially, having never been captured themselves, responded to the dangerous mask with real but somewhat less exact recognition.
Why imperfect information is still worth having
From an evolutionary standpoint, this trade-off makes sense. Being captured, however briefly and safely in this case, is a costly way to learn; a genuine predator encounter would be considerably more so. Cheap social information, even diluted in precision, still shifts the odds in a young or naive bird’s favour compared with having no information at all. Treated as a proxy for firsthand experience rather than a full substitute, socially transmitted alarm appears to be worth its imperfections.
What the finding does and doesn’t support
The pattern is solid evidence that specific, usable information about a particular threat can spread through a crow population well beyond the individuals originally involved, including to naive offspring. It does not, on its own, establish deliberate teaching in a strict sense. Vigilant caution is warranted before describing this capacity as crow “culture” in the fuller sense that term carries elsewhere in animal behaviour research.
Listening
ListeningDiluted, Not Absent — Key Points
Speaking
SpeakingRules: Two teams. 4 minutes each. 1+ participle clause + 1 vocabulary word.
Writing
WritingChoose one option. 150–200 words. 2+ participle clauses + 3 vocab words + 1 specific reference to the case.
Option B — Argumentative: “Information that has lost precision in transmission is not meaningfully different from no information at all.” Evaluate this claim using the crow case.
Option C — Opinion: Do you think Miriam is right to withhold the word “culture” from this finding? Give your reasoned opinion, acknowledging the limits of the evidence.

